Pashinyan is ready to recognize Artsakh as part of Azerbaijan: What next
During his December 24, 2021 press conference, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan made several statements and assertions on the current situation in Nagorno Karabakh and his vision for its future. He rejected the idea to demand the withdrawal of Azerbaijani forces from any territories, which they captured during the 2020 Karabakh war, including the territories of the former Nagorno Karabakh Autonomous Oblast (the entire Hadrut region, several villages of the Martakert, Martuni and Askeran regions and Shushi city). According to Pashinyan, the Azerbaijani population which lived in the former NKAO (according to the 1989 Soviet Union census, Azerbaijanis made up 22.4 percent of the NKAO population, while the number of Armenians was 76.4 percent) had the right to return, and the capture of Hadrut region, Shushi and other territories created the possibility for the realization of that right. This narrative puts Armenians currently living in Nagorno Karabakh in a perilous situation, as the de facto new line of contact fixed by the November 10, 2020 trilateral statement established a tiny entity which is not viable neither politically nor economically. However, according to Pashinyan, Armenia will not demand independence even for that small entity of approximately 3,000 square kilometers. The prime minister stated that Nagorno Karabakh lost all chances not to be part of Azerbaijan back in 2016. So, if there were no such chances when the territory of the unrecognized Nagorno Karabakh Republic was 11450 square kilometers, there definitely could be no chances now. The prime minister stated that his vision is to see Armenians living in Karabakh safely and securely, which means that Armenia is ready to move forward and sign a peace treaty with Azerbaijan if Baku provides some guarantees for the security of Armenians. Theoretically, it could be a written guarantee put in the peace treaty with no status, or it could be some status of cultural autonomy for Nagorno Karabakh within the November 10, 2020 statement borders, providing Armenians the opportunity to study the Armenian language in Azerbaijani schools or have several hours of daily Armenian language broadcasts on Stepanakert radio.
Already a subscriber?Log in here
This story is FREE for you...
Create a free account to access this and four more articles, and get more sent to you with our e-newsletter.By submitting your email address you agree for Hairenik Association, Inc. to send you communication by email.
Unbelievable. This filthy scum Pashinyan should be executed for cowardice and treason. And what will happen if this ridiculous concession to Aliyev is allowed, Syunik will be next, then one more big push and Armenia will be gone forever.As a human being this piece of excrement is totally worthless.
Thanks Benyamin, Well written and passionate article.
I was shocked when this government re-elected after that debacle. Though, we are where we are. It is much harder to retake what you have lost, than protecting it in the first place. Hence, such a concession should be avoided, even such a rumour should be condemned (As you did). Patriotism is honourable, but it needs to be supported and backed with deterrence. People (You and me, …) can act as catalyst and demand the governors to act responsibly and seek support from all available sources to protect the security and sovereignty of a small country with ~2.9 M population. As you mentioned, Russia can be of assistance. Russians try to be seen as neutral, and they pursuit their interests. Same can be said about Iran. Although it has its own challenges to deal with, but it is time for President of Armenia not the Prime minister (as he lost/ presumed that he lost his credibility due to loosing Armenian territory) to step-up and pay visit to the southern neighbour’s counterpart and facilitate construction of 50+ Km of alternative road, establishment of a security base, protection of borders, supply, and logistics, etc. There are shared interests which needs to be exploited in-full, and time is of the essence. Despite, argument about religion, etc. Armenia and Armenians are dear to Iran and Iranians, and there is no doubt who is the aggressor (examples; Iran Iraq 1980-1988, Iran and Ottoman during Safavid era, did the aggressor manage to take a square inch? NO), Aggression will be responded by your neighbour, provided that your neighbour has a mandate (e.g. defence treaty, defence base supporting mutual assets, e.g., roads, borders, etc.). Weakness of a neighbour at any point of time, does not provide entitlement for annexation of the land. otherwise, defined borders by imperial powers could have been shifted several time in past 20 years to east, west and north.
Take your medication. You don’t speak for Iranians. Iran is going to attack Turkey and Azerbaycan for Armenia? Your mad. Iran only cares about having a land bridge to Lebanon. You never respond to any comments from anyone so I do not expect an answer back from you this time around. Stay in your bubble.
Even Russia didn’t do anything and Russia is Turkey’s mortal enemy.
Majority of the Turkey – Iran borders were drawn during the 17th century. Nothing has been in dispute ever since. Why would Iran attack Turkey?
where is Tehlirian when we need him most!
Anyone that wanted to get rid of the “Russian backed oligarchs” and supported this Western and Turkish financed traitor in 2018 has no right to complain today. Karma is you know what. Be careful of what you wish for. God bless democracy, westernization, progress, people power and the American way…
Stated simply – the human rights of the indigenous people of Artsakh are not being supported by the current government of Armenia. Either Pashinyan does not care about the Armenians in Artsakh or he and his cronies have been paid off to surrender. There is no middle ground.
Thank you Benjamain
Your analysis is entirely correct but there is one more thing that has not been calculated, which is the assassination of the traitors not by the Tashnagtsoutyoun but by people who are passionate about eradicating these pests. This will also include assassination of ambassadors. Unfortunately, the days of peaceful transition are over and as a diaspora after siphoning 100 billion dollars of OUR money as you stated they are interested in buying their BMW, their LEXUS and their prostitutes and the list goes on. This will end and it HAS to end. Nothing will resurrect our nation unless a good bloodbath that includes the current and previous junta. This mess is not just the making of the current idiot but dates back 30 years in the making. So as a simple message, please stop helping the regime and help the wounded directly. No more telethons and no more donations for hayastan all armenian fund. Enough is enough. Hope this resonates with the pacifist armenians worldwide and they start waking up.
If this is actually the way you think you’re either very young or an idiot. We had this same action brought true by a Dashnak in 1999 and it was a disaster. Use common sense and logic rather than whatever radical nationalism you have been taught or are reading online.
Also it seems people don’t have reading or listening comprehension with these Dec 24 comments. Pashinyan was stating where the negotiations were at and the terms that had been imposed since 2016, which was that Artsakh was only going to be able to exist within Azerbaijan. This was a term that he was attempting to change which was obviously a failure. Please use critical thinking when reviewing the events of the last 25 years and who is responsible for what.
Well said Shahe Boghossian. Knowing the situation we are in the present moment, I can only say you are only dreaming.
Overall excellent article, except for the part about Nubar Afeyan and Ruben Vardanyan. The two are nothing but cogs in the Globalist empire. Globalism and Westernization brought Armenia to this low point in history.
As an American citizen it pains me to say this but frankly Armenia and Artsakh would be better off as a province in Russia akin to Quebec in Canada. Have strong laws to preserve language and culture but be under the FULL protection of Russia. Otherwise the Turks and Azeris will keep on coming and within 60 years there will be no Artsakh OR Armenia left.
Let’s face it. In the paradigm of the US State Department Israel is to be protected at all costs. Azerbaijan provides 40% of Israeli oil imports while also providing a parking area for Israel’s F15’s for a quick strike on Iran. So Azerbaijan gets a free pass to carry on an ethnic cleansing campaign. Face it, the United States is not Armenia’s friend and if anything it is Armenia’s enemy.
I don’t know why people are sounding surprised at pashinyan abandoning Artakh. It has been his plan all along, since way before 2018. For the last 20 years he has been spewing this pro-azeri “anti-kharabagh” sentiment together with his wife in his NED sponsored newspaper and finally reached his dream. It is a continuation of Levon Ter Petrosyan and Jurayr Libaridian’s ideology of the 90’s. The sad thing is that despite this, the Armenian people enthusiastically embraced him both in the homeland and the diaspora. Furthermore they voted for him again in June 2021. This is a bigger red flag to me than what nikol says or does and clearly illustrates that democracy assumes a level of political literacy which our people just don’t have. For us, democracy is a poison that has been weaponized and used against us.
It’s just awful. Pashinyan just gives in, gives land and appeases a predatory and fanatically Armenophobic Azerbaijan, and eventually Turkey, with the “encouragement” (pressure) by the “ally” Russia. He gave up Artsakh, which in four years time could well be completely ethnically cleansed of its native Armenian inhabitants and all Armenian heritage completely destroyed by the Azeris, once the five year “peacekeeping” mission of Russia ends. The Azeris already destroyed numerous Armenian churches, cemeteries and other artifacts under their control, which should have been a wake up call, after Pashinyan signed that shameful capitulation. The destruction of Armenian heritage in Artsakh did not even elicit condemnation by the “international community” or even make the international news. No one should be surprised if he gives up even land of the Republic of Armenia to the two Turkic archenemies, so they can have their corridor for their pan-Turkist Greater Azerbaijan/Neo-Ottoman empire. If history, especially Armenia’s tragic history taught us anything, one cannot appease a predatory power for a “peace with honor”, and expect it to honor it and become tame. And still the people continue to vote for this traitor. I don’t know of any other country, where a traitor would be kept in office. It’s just incomprehensible and mind-boggling.
The best possible scenario for Armenia is to join in some form of federalism with Russia 🇷🇺, similar to Belarus. This scenario will allow both Armenia and Artsakh to keep their land and independence. Under such an arrangement, Russia will provide security guarantees to Armenia and Artsakh. We will not lose our children to war. In addition, we will prosper and stop outMigration. Let’s not forget, before independence, in 1991, the population of Armenia was 3.8 million. Today’s Armenia is not more than 2.3 million. 1.5 million Armenians have left their country. How is this possible in nation building dreams we might have ? Besides, during Soviet Armenia, we had a vibrant educational system, culture, music, literature and preserved our language, history and heritage. Most Armenias who live in Armenia say they were much better offduring the Soviet era then than at present. Think about it. What I say is not so bad, after all.
LOL – you have got to be joking. I hope?
Are you talking about the same Russia that:
-cut Armenia up and gave parts to Turkey, Azerbaijan and Georgia?
Are you talking about the same Russia that:
-Favored Azerbaijan over Armenia for a century despite exploiting Armenia?
Are you talking about the same Russia that:
-Stopped Artsakh from winning the war in 1994?
Are you talking about the same Russia that:
-Started arming Azerbaijan after 1994 while telling Armenia “only peace”?
Are you talking about the same Russia that:
-Forced Armenia to join it’s poverty club while FAVORING AZERI-TURK POLICY?
Are you talking about the same Russia that:
-Forced Armenia to reduce Iran gas import and sell the pipes to Russia?
Are you talking about the same Russia that:
-Makes Armenia pay its expenses to protect Russian interests in Gyumri?
Are you talking about the same Russia that:
-Ordered Armenia to release a mass-murdering Russian soldier to send home?
Are you talking about the same Russia that:
-Sat back and watched ISIS terrorists sent by Turkey to Artsakh?
Are you talking about the same Russia that:
-Does nothing while Azerbaijan invades Armenia now despite (phony) “treaties”?
You see, as a diaspora Armenian you have fallen victim to the classic Russian psy-op, which also involves it’s ‘Armenian’ poodles that spread unpatriotic propaganda about how “we need Russia and we may not criticize Mother Russia under any circumstances”, and that “this is what happens when a nation betrays Russia”.
If “criticism” on Russia had any effect on Russian Policy, Azerbaijan would have been removed from existence 20 years ago. But of course, these propaganda conditions are always applied to Armenia, not other nations.
As to your “Most Armenias who live in Armenia say they were much better offduring the Soviet era then than at present” comment, you are correct but not for the reason you are intending. The real reason is, under Russian Soviet regressive policy for decades, the people of Armenia turned lazy, and in order to maintain a lifestyle barely above the poverty level, they had to “steal from the state”. After 30 years, nothing has actually changed with their mentality, that’s why we lost 30 years with their lies and theft. The diaspora practiced patriotism while the ignorant class of “leadership” in Armenia practices theft. That’s the real reason we lost Artsakh, not because of the inability of our fighters.
Ask yourself this important question. Why is the Ukraine, a nation essentially of the same race, religion and culture of Russia, wanting to break free of the Russian stranglehold? The answer is very simple: those who trust and shack up with Russia end up getting used, abused, and then tossed away. The 100 year history of Armenia has shown this beyond any doubt.
PAshinyan doesn’t go to Artsakh at the request if Azerbaijan. Imagine that? Pashinyan wanted to lose this war. That is clear. Thats why he purposely didn’t mobilize the Armenian Army. Purposely lied at every turn as he does today. He let Artsakh alone to defend itself. Remember Armenia was the protector of Artsakhs security. Not any more. He allowed 45oo Armenians to die just so his dreams of no more Artsakh becomes real and hes can then pretend that its not his fault but blame the past rulers in charge, who BTW liberated land and kept it under Armenian control..He IS A TRAITOR to ALL ARMENIANS. NEVER FORGET THAT!