Editorials
Armenia is Not a Beneficiary of the Global Economy—It’s a Prisoner
In this week’s issue, we published the English translation of a recent opinion piece, authored by former advisor to Armenia’s Prime Minister, Igor Zargaryan, who has recently formed a new political party, National Agenda. In the article, which has been shared across numerous local publications, Zargaryan outlines his vision of what economic success could look like for Armenia, and critiques recent calls by Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan for “economic revolution.”




In his 2012 book “Why Nations Fail” Daron Acemoglu names one exemplary – model country: Botswana! But do you see people risking their lives on unsafe boats trying to go live in Botswana?
People vote with their feet.
PM Nikol Pashinyan is only promising a “Երջանիկ Հայաստան”. I am sure he knows that we cannot have a prosperous, consumer society, when we have one of the highest per-capita defence-spending in the world. Besides, a consumer-society leads to environmental degradation.
Will PM Pashinyan be able to lead Armenia towards a “happy society”? One factor he can count on is that Armenia also has one of the highest ethnically-religiously-linguistically homogeneous populations of any nation-state in the world.
Can we build a society of caring for one another and for our environment? A society of mutual respect? I believe we can, but it will take time.
“Unlike Zargarian, I agree that Armenia needs an economic revolution—but only because I believe the rest of the world needs one far more desperately.”
I cannot agree more with this. Let’s say a small country like Armenia decides to impose a progressive tax system. The problem today is that, given global capitalism, the capital will simply move out of the country and go where it can exploit more freely. I agree that the solution lies at the level of global thinking, cooperation between transnational entities. With the growing threats posed from (1) ecology, our shared natural substance, (2) advancements in biogenetics, the potential to manipulate our genetic inheritance, (3) intellectual property, and (4) new forms of apartheid, it is clear that we can no longer leave these just to the market or the state; something larger is needed. The space of the ‘commons’ is today under threat
“Living in Armenia, I saw what real poverty looked like; and that poverty was not just to be found in the crumbling cement facades of Soviet-era socialist apartment buildings. Real poverty can be found in the mind-numbing cultural and environmental void created by an industrial economy, which privileges corporations over communities”
Do you really think that poverty in Armenia is caused by not caring about the environment? I will leave out what you call “cultural void” for now…
What about corruption, underdevelopment, economic blockade and almost non-existent public services?
How does the “poisonous mining tailing” in your picture actually contribute to the poverty in Kapan?