Excellent article raising excellent questions as well as keen observations. I applaud the author. I think it important for those in Turkey to understand the thoughts expressed here as a primary reason for caution from the Diaspora and, thus, why there is not always as supportive a response to their activities in Turkey as they would expect. All generalizations are just that, but still the author has captured the essence of a broad range of actors involved in this issue both inside and outside of Turkey. Again thank you for sharing.
Great questions. I will never call standing up for freedom ‘foolhardy.’ Life is meaningless without it and those Bolsahays “who do not stay home” ARE warriors for the cause.
While public statements by Turkey’s leaders appear to represent a softening, a transforming attitude, what has really changed? Didn’t the young Turks start out making statements advocating inclusivity and democracy, giving Armenians false hope for equality in the empire? We all know how that turned out. I think very little has changed. I fear the genocidal cancer of 100 years ago is merely in a state of remission. No societal soul-searching has occurred to remove the tumor of ultra-nationalism. No just compensation to Armenia has been made as repentance for a crime. Even Erdogan’s public remarks of 2014 were less apology than amelioration of guilt with talk of shared pain.
Yes, they are warriors—and particularly courageous ones—taking an overt stand for justice in a covertly hostile environment.
As was mentioned many times before nothing has changed in Turkey regarding the Armenians. Few examples that prove this. The Killing of a peaceful Armenian like Hrant Dink. The present leader Erdoghan being insulted to be called Armenian and the same with Abdulla Gul. Erdoghan threathening to send 100,000 Armenian workers to Armenia as a revenge for Armenians claiming recognition of the Genocide.The Anti Armenian demonstrations by the Turks all over the world. And my own personal experience when in Jordan a bus load of octaganarian Turks were heading to Mecca for their pilgrimage. One of them was boasting of killing so many Armenian Christians ( Gavours) and now he is going to Mecca to complete his religious duty towards God. I myself would not like to see our boarder with Turkey opened even if they recognise the Genocide as the door will then be opened for Turks to invest in our country and not only Western Armenia will be in Turkey and in Turkish hands but also present Armenia . It’s therefore the duty of every Diaspora Armenian to get together and invest in our country and improve our country’s economy and make it self sustainable in order to stop the outward migration if we want our country to survive.
Why shouldn’t Armenian citizens of Turkey take advantage of their constitutional right to peaceful freedom of assembly and speech. Yes, I agree, there are no guarantees that such public protests may not “backfire” on the community, but as the adage says, “Nothing gained ,nothing ventured”. As citizens, do not Armenians have the right, nay, obligation, to cooperate with those individuals and groups in Turkey struggling for progressive change? Yes, there are risks but I would venture to state that the days of a hidden Armenian millet, silent and cowed, are coming to an end. Younger generations of Istanbul-Armenians, as far as I know, have a much greater sense of Turkish citizenship then their elders. Many no longer carry the “baggage” of their parents. For them, the future path is to remain in Turkey and utilize their rights as citizens to fight for change. Ask the members of the “Nor Zartonk” (New Awakening) movement how they view such actions. Naturally, if, out of a community of 50-60,000 only a 1/4 of less believe in such an approach, they will need supporters in the greater society. Evidently, there appears to be a core of Turks and Kurds (as well as others) who see the resolution of the Armenian “question” as an essential component of the democratization process in Turkey.
Thank you Nareg for your report from Istanbul. It’s interesting to hear about what was going in Bolis on April 24th. I was curious about the composition of the crowds in the streets.
Excellent article raising excellent questions as well as keen observations. I applaud the author. I think it important for those in Turkey to understand the thoughts expressed here as a primary reason for caution from the Diaspora and, thus, why there is not always as supportive a response to their activities in Turkey as they would expect. All generalizations are just that, but still the author has captured the essence of a broad range of actors involved in this issue both inside and outside of Turkey. Again thank you for sharing.
Great questions. I will never call standing up for freedom ‘foolhardy.’ Life is meaningless without it and those Bolsahays “who do not stay home” ARE warriors for the cause.
While public statements by Turkey’s leaders appear to represent a softening, a transforming attitude, what has really changed? Didn’t the young Turks start out making statements advocating inclusivity and democracy, giving Armenians false hope for equality in the empire? We all know how that turned out. I think very little has changed. I fear the genocidal cancer of 100 years ago is merely in a state of remission. No societal soul-searching has occurred to remove the tumor of ultra-nationalism. No just compensation to Armenia has been made as repentance for a crime. Even Erdogan’s public remarks of 2014 were less apology than amelioration of guilt with talk of shared pain.
Yes, they are warriors—and particularly courageous ones—taking an overt stand for justice in a covertly hostile environment.
As was mentioned many times before nothing has changed in Turkey regarding the Armenians. Few examples that prove this. The Killing of a peaceful Armenian like Hrant Dink. The present leader Erdoghan being insulted to be called Armenian and the same with Abdulla Gul. Erdoghan threathening to send 100,000 Armenian workers to Armenia as a revenge for Armenians claiming recognition of the Genocide.The Anti Armenian demonstrations by the Turks all over the world. And my own personal experience when in Jordan a bus load of octaganarian Turks were heading to Mecca for their pilgrimage. One of them was boasting of killing so many Armenian Christians ( Gavours) and now he is going to Mecca to complete his religious duty towards God. I myself would not like to see our boarder with Turkey opened even if they recognise the Genocide as the door will then be opened for Turks to invest in our country and not only Western Armenia will be in Turkey and in Turkish hands but also present Armenia . It’s therefore the duty of every Diaspora Armenian to get together and invest in our country and improve our country’s economy and make it self sustainable in order to stop the outward migration if we want our country to survive.
Why shouldn’t Armenian citizens of Turkey take advantage of their constitutional right to peaceful freedom of assembly and speech. Yes, I agree, there are no guarantees that such public protests may not “backfire” on the community, but as the adage says, “Nothing gained ,nothing ventured”. As citizens, do not Armenians have the right, nay, obligation, to cooperate with those individuals and groups in Turkey struggling for progressive change? Yes, there are risks but I would venture to state that the days of a hidden Armenian millet, silent and cowed, are coming to an end. Younger generations of Istanbul-Armenians, as far as I know, have a much greater sense of Turkish citizenship then their elders. Many no longer carry the “baggage” of their parents. For them, the future path is to remain in Turkey and utilize their rights as citizens to fight for change. Ask the members of the “Nor Zartonk” (New Awakening) movement how they view such actions. Naturally, if, out of a community of 50-60,000 only a 1/4 of less believe in such an approach, they will need supporters in the greater society. Evidently, there appears to be a core of Turks and Kurds (as well as others) who see the resolution of the Armenian “question” as an essential component of the democratization process in Turkey.
Thank you Nareg for your report from Istanbul. It’s interesting to hear about what was going in Bolis on April 24th. I was curious about the composition of the crowds in the streets.