Youth
Summers on Kınalıada: The island that keeps Armenian culture alive
Growing up Armenian in Turkey, my existence has never been passive. Rather, it has been an act of resistance.
Growing up Armenian in Turkey, my existence has never been passive. Rather, it has been an act of resistance.
Already a subscriber?Log in here
That the faces of the people in the photos are blurred, is very telling about the precarious situation of the Armenians in Istanbul and of the other non-Muslim minorities, the Jews and Greeks, who are systematically discriminated by the Turkish state, overwhelmingly reviled and shunned by the Turks, and are steadily decreasing. They are afraid and rightly so.
I personally experienced this timidity of the Armenians around Turks, while I visited Turkey (Istanbul and Hatay Province, where the last Armenian village in Turkey called Vakifli is situated) in April 2005. They were guarded with their answers in the presence of Turks and I didn’t dare ask them about the Armenian Genocide and the 1955 Istanbul Pogrom, so not to get them and myself into trouble with Turkish officialdom, because acknowledging the Armenian Genocide is punishable under Article 301 of the Turkish Penal Code for “Insulting the Turkish Nation”.
That is why, the dwindling Armenian, Jewish and Greek communities seclude themselves from the Turkish majority as much as they can, in order to shield themselves from abuse, which is very hard to do, because their names and surnames often give their identities away and their numbers are too small to form ethnic ghettos, which was the case at least until the 1955 Istanbul Pogrom, which started the continuous exodus of the non-Muslim minorities. Before 1955 at the earliest, Kinaliada was once majority Armenian.
The exodus of Armenians accelerated after the assassination of Hrant Dink in 2007, and of the Jews in 2009, after the falling out between Turkey and Israel over Gaza and Hamas. Since 2007, the Armenian community’s numbers fell from 50,000 to just below 40,000, since 2009, the Jewish community’s numbers fell from 25,000 to 13,000, and the Greek community’s numbers hover around 1,000.
Considering the violent history of Turks against these ethnic groups, expecting a future for them in Turkey is a fallacy, and in Istanbul an impossibility.
What a wonderful young man who is sowing the seeds of generational memories.
Thank You!
Kınalıada isn’t just a summer retreat—it’s a living archive of Armenian memory, ritual, and joy.
Deni,
Congratulations on a well written article! It was beautiful and informative!
Thank You!
Dear Teminyan…Thanks for sharing your experience at Kinaliada island. I visited that island at the end of October of 2019. I was with a group from Armenia. Out guide said that at the end of the Octobe not much going on at the island. However we enjoyed seeing the summer homes of the Armenians, of course only from the outside. we also vidited the church and we had a late lunch at a café by the sea. Thanks for bringing out attention to Kinaliada island.
Thank you for your kind words
Deni, it was a pleasure to read your sentiments and your report. I was reminded of my college years when with friends, I visited Istanbul, and then Varna, naturally connecting to Armenians as much as we could. We visited the island but I remember it as the Kenali island where, were told that Armenians vacation. But that was over 50 years ago! I understand the number of Armenians has dwindled precipitously in Istanbul, but I read that nowadays there are 16 Armenian schools, 3 Armenian newspapers, 39 active Armenian churches. On a personal note, political unrest in middle east brought havoc upon once thriving Armenian communities there. The Armenia community in Istanbul was spared from such havoc but obviously not the unavoidable attrition of Diaspora communities. Well done, thank you.
Thank you very much!
Thank you Deni for putting your heart into words. By writing this well thought article you connected our tiny island with many Armenians around the world and also made your memories carved into Kinaliada history.
Mersi Sayat Apar