In Sight

Armenians should not confuse allies and empathy

Sometimes failure is the best way to learn and grow. It is said that the opportunity for prosperity comes from surviving adversity. It’s true, but only if we choose to invest in our learning. Experiencing hardship and repeating the same mistakes is the definition of chronic failure. Most of us have spent the better part of the last two and a half months venting our grief and frustration over losses by rightfully criticizing the establishment…but without a serious alternative. The reality of our dilemma is that our dissatisfaction is neutralized by the absence of a strategic solution. The honest part of our venting needs to be directed at the subculture we have created. Our tolerance for mediocrity must end. Our recovery starts by setting the bar higher. The natural response to our isolation is to say that we must only rely on ourselves. This is partially true when you consider the dramatic changes needed in military readiness, diplomacy, intelligence and the economy. 

Already a subscriber?Log in here

This story is FREE for you...

Create a free account to access this and four more articles, and get more sent to you with our e-newsletter.

Or, subscribe now for unlimited access
By submitting your email address you agree for Hairenik Association, Inc. to send you communication by email.

Stepan Piligian

Stepan Piligian was raised in the Armenian community of Indian Orchard, Massachusetts, at the St. Gregory Parish. A former member of the AYF Central Executive, he is active in the Armenian community. Currently, he serves on the board of the Armenian Heritage Foundation. Stepan is a retired executive in the computer storage industry and resides in the Boston area with his wife Susan. He has spent many years as a volunteer teacher of Armenian history and contemporary issues to the young generation and adults at schools, camps and churches. His interests include the Armenian diaspora, Armenia, sports and reading.

7 Comments

  1. Stepan, don’t take this personally, but these articles are just too much at this point. November 10th was nearly 3 months ago at this point, and we have had enough time to vent and rant about the world’s betrayal.

    The criticisms of the west, Russia, and Iran have already been repeated in a plethora of articles by a multitude of authors at this point. We get it.

    Let’s rebuild our relationship with these 3 (west, Russia, Iran) and find new ways to entice them. We need to move away from the old thinking that the west will help us because we’re Christian and democratic; that Russia will help us because we’re Christian and their close ally; and that Iran will help us because we’re their neighbour and ally.

    Finding new ways to engage with these 3 is important and more productive than constantly talking about our frustration.

  2. Very thoughtful set of considerations and suggestions. I was struck by the assertion, in the penultimate paragraph, that “if the US and Russia would limit their rivalry for a moment, Turkey would be the loser.” It might as well be said of US relations with Iran. Whenever US (and Western) relations with Russia and Iran are severely strained, Armenia suffers, even if it is unintentional. Unfortunately, there seems to be scant prospect at the moment of an easing of those existing tensions. Ideally, we should be aiming for lasting stability in the region.

  3. I agree with author. Armenia had no allies but geopolitical situation is not static. I believe tables can turn but drastic measures have to be in place. Pashinyan’s government has proven to be ineffective and frankly harmful for Armenia. The way he handle war, negotiations etc. raise number of questions. He needs to go. Professionals have to replace his government

    1. you all guy always complain being pashinian fualt he did the best what was left to sattle he saved artzakh and armenia. let get united and help each other and ceate a united armenian and rtzakh

  4. When you don’t listen to your biggest ally (Russia), and you don’t listen to the your other friendly powers (USA, France), and you think you can resist what they want, that is the return of the five territories—eventually you get what you deserve.

  5. The reason of loss was incompetency and its symbol traitor Nikol. Why to blame Russia when we have traitor Nikol. Who bought planes without rockets, who bought obsolete air defense system from Jordan, … it is funny at the end of war they had taken Seryan Ohanyan out of court, made him commander of Shushi!!! Or Gagik Tsarukyan literally came out of prison to organize defense detachments. This incompetents were brought to power to do what they did, now why we should blame others.

  6. Very good article. Thank you, Mr. Pilgian.

    The reason Russia has supported Armenia is that it is Russia’s only ally in the Caucasus — and indeed probably Russia’s only real ally anywhere, period.

    Most importantly, Armenia serves as a pan-Turkic blocker. Otherwise, NATO would soon own the entire Caucasus and Caspian.

    This war was a *Russian* war from start to finish.

    Russia stopped the war when it wanted to, so it could have stopped the war before it started. Let there be no doubt.

    Essentially, Putin had a temper tantrum at Armenians for no good reason. Armenia never changed its pro-Russian foreign policy and military orientation one iota, no matter what you may think of Pashinyan.

    Pashinyan’s predecessors ALL reached out to the West in major ways.

    Putin has now let Turkey and, therefore, NATO and pan-Turkism into the Caucasus right up to the Caspian Sea.

    By what illogic is that good for Russia?
    By what illogic is the empowered pan-Turkish duo of Turkey and Azerbaijan in Russia’s interests?
    By what illogic is the war’s destabilization of Iran good for Russia?
    By what illogic is increased Israeli (and thus US) post-war influence in Azerbaijan good for Russia?

    Putin and Russia do not have the slightest idea what they are doing.

Back to top button