Bohjalian: Murder Cannot Be Hid Long. The Truth Will Out.

The Armenian Weekly Magazine
April 2015: A Century of Resistance

In March I spent three days at “Responsibility 2015,” the conference on the Armenian Genocide sponsored by the Armenian Revolutionary Federation held in Manhattan. At the end of the final day, I was at once invigorated and exhausted. I was inspired by the passion of the artists and activists and intellectuals, and I was emotionally wrung out by the realities of imagining for three days the genocide that a century ago this month was commencing.

It was impossible not to contemplate my visits to Western Armenia, and what I have seen there. I was brought back to Van and Kharpert and Diyarbakir. I was brought back to Chunkush and the Dudan Crevasse. And I was brought back to Digor.

The St. Sargis Church sits hidden on a ledge halfway down a steep ravine. (photo: Victoria Blewer)
The St. Sargis Church sits hidden on a ledge halfway down a steep ravine. (photo: Victoria Blewer)

Digor isn’t on a lot of the maps that we Armenian pilgrims follow on our journeys back into the world that was ours once. It’s a town of about 2,500 people, mostly Kurds. But it’s not far from Ani. It’s no more than 20 miles from the Armenian border. The editor of this newspaper, Nanore Barsoumian, has been there. So has her predecessor, Khatchig Mouradian.

At some point in the 1950’s, a small Turkish military contingent drove to a rocky plateau west of Digor and placed dynamite inside the five medieval stone churches that comprised the isolated Armenian monastery of Khdzgonk. And then they blew them up.

Most of them, anyway. I had heard that one proud section of the largest of the five churches, St. Sargis, was still standing.

We all know the appalling lengths to which Turkey will go to deny the genocide. We know the government is pathologic; we know that it approaches the culpability of the Ottoman regime with a despicable, Stalin-like determination to rewrite history via lies and bluster and threats.

But if you want to see firsthand the lengths to which the government has gone to deny the historical reality of the Armenian presence on the Anatolian plains, visit St. Sargis. I journeyed there last summer with my family.

St. Sargis is not easy to find. The monastery compound is only eight miles as the crow flies from Digor, but it sits hidden on a ledge halfway down a steep ravine. We only found it because we were traveling with Khatchig, who knew the mayor of Digor, who, in turn, offered us a guide from the village to lead us there.

But we hiked through the desert-like hills to the edge of a plateau, looked down, and there it was: St. Sargis. The center of the church and the iconic Armenian dome, despite great gaping holes in the walls, had survived the blast.

St. Sargis Church (photo: Victoria Blewer)
St. Sargis Church (photo: Victoria Blewer)

I remember wondering when I was climbing several hundred feet down the vertigo-inducing ridge into the sheltered ravine, did the Turkish soldiers lower their dynamite over the side of the cliff with pulleys and ropes, or did they carry it in their packs? Clearly they’d needed a lot: I’d seen black and white photographs of the five-church compound. The churches had been constructed between the 11th and 13th centuries, and they had been built to last.

I’ve visited a lot of Armenian ruins across Historic Armenia—perhaps as many as 30 or 40 different monasteries and churches in places that most North Americans outside of our community couldn’t find on a map. In some ways, it’s reminiscent of visiting a castle keep in Scotland or the ancient city in Rome. The soul wonders at the past and we are left wistful by the ephemerality of our lives.

But here is how it is different: Often these ruins—while as old as some Roman temples or the remnants of a tower in the Scottish highlands—were the homes to vital, vibrant, and active congregations or monasteries a mere hundred years ago. When Babe Ruth was playing baseball. When Scott Fitzgerald was honing his craft. When Alexander Graham Bell in New York was ringing a fellow named Watson in California.

By the 1950’s, when the locals who live in Digor recall the Turkish soldiers blowing up the 5 churches, the monastery had been sitting empty for less than 40 years.

Today much of the rubble has disappeared back into the earth. Scrub brush and dirt have slowly buried the shattered stonework, as well as the walls of the chapels that were blown out and into the nearby crevasse.

The last stage in any genocide is denial. My sense is that’s why decades after evicting the monks, the Turks tried to blow up the site—one of perhaps dozens of churches they would destroy in the 1950’s.

It wasn’t enough to ethnically cleanse the Armenians from the country; it was important to scour away any trace that once upon a time we had lived there, too—even in a ravine in the absolute middle of nowhere.

It wasn’t enough to ethnically cleanse the Armenians from the country; it was important to scour away any trace that once upon a time we had lived there, too—even in a ravine in the absolute middle of nowhere. My wife and I speculated that the only reason St. Sargis remains is because the soldiers ran out of dynamite and it was too much work to bother coming back to finish the job.

But, as Shakespeare observed, the truth will out.

The full quote is even more meaningful here: “Truth will come to light; murder cannot be hid long…at the length truth will out.”

Indeed: Murder cannot be hid long.

As drained as I was at the end of “Responsibility 2015,” I was also confident that we—Armenians—are winning. We really are. While so many of our ancestors’ voices were stilled, their descendants are speaking more passionately and powerfully than ever. “Long” is a relevant term. A century is but a blink in geologic terms.

You can blow up a monastery. But you can’t bulldoze the truth.

 

The paperback of Chris Bohjalian’s most recent novel, Close Your Eyes, Hold Hands, was published in May.

avatar

Chris Bohjalian

Chris Bohjalian is the author of 19 books, including the New York Times bestsellers The Sandcastle Girls, The Night Strangers, Skeletons at the Feast, and The Double Bind. His novel Midwives was a number one New York Times bestseller and a selection of Oprah’s Book Club. His work has been translated into more than 25 languages, and three of his novels have become movies. Bohjalian’s most recent novel, The Sleepwalker, was published in Jan. 2017. Bohjalian’s awards include the ANCA Freedom Award for his work educating Americans about the Armenian Genocide; the ANCA Arts and Letters Award for The Sandcastle Girls; the Saint Mesrob Mashdots Medal; and the Anahid Literary Award.
avatar

Latest posts by Chris Bohjalian (see all)

15 Comments

  1. I feel pain in my heart when I see these type of images! This a crime against art and culture, which are more important than humanity! They stay forever and we move on! What these barbarian Turks have been doing is no different than what ISIS is doing in Syria, Iraq…… Shame on them and shame on our government that supports them!

  2. I am deeply touched with the published story about the visit to Saint Sargis Church. It’s existence tells that Armenian nation will leave forever and no one can kill us. We have to become stronger and stronger, larger and larger and hopefully sometime in future we will reside our homeland that turks have robbed… I wish I could publish my poems in Armenian Weekly, which are devoted to Centennial of the Armenian Genocide. Please, tell me how I can do that. Whom I should address my e-mail message with poems?

  3. It is too painfull to read the story let alone step into the ravine and witness the ruins. I commend Chris for his courage to go on such a difficult pilgrimage and share his experience with his readers.

  4. Arthur Schopenhawer: All truth passes through three stages:
    First, it is ridiculed;
    Second, it is violently opposed;
    Third, it is accepted as self-evident

  5. I was very touched as well. What an experience it must of been,visiting the ruins of St.Sargis,Kharpet,Diyarbakir, and all the other villages and towns. Sand Castle Girls is a must read for everyone,would make a great movie.

  6. Chris, this is one of the saddest and yet most beautiful reflections to appear in these pages. Thank you for writing it, and for sharing the haunting photograph.

  7. Khtzkonk monastery was actually demolished in two stages. The damage to the St. Sarkis church was inflicted in the early to mid 1960s. It is this event that is remembered by the villagers in Digor. The other four churches were probably destroyed in the 1950s. The scatter pattern of the masonry fragments indicate that both stages involved the use of high explosives. There is no particular difficulty in visiting Khtzkonk – one merely has to walk there. From Digor is the longest route at two hours, but is the easiest. From the pumice quarry on the plateau down to the valley via one of the numerous trails is shorter, taking maybe one hour, and still fairly easy. The shortest route, the original approach to the monastery, is about 40 minutes: from the plateau along the track to the stone-paved “platform” is very easy but the scramble from there down to the monastery is a bit difficult. Whatever route chosen, the goal of actually entering the church will soon not be possible. There are plans by the World Monuments Fund, the current experts in destroying Armenians sites in Turkey, to prohibit access to the surviving church, probably by surrounding the site by a security fence and walling up the gaps in the church’s walls.

  8. Enough telling it to ourselves! Send a copy of this or forward it to Mr. Moon, the United Nations Secretary General, and all the others of same ilk, who piously toe the Turkish line “let the historian examine and decide”, like he shamelessly did around April 24. Besides, there is a sure way to turn the table on that excuse for not taking responsibilty, if we will just have the guts to do it, but that is another subject.

  9. Very impressive and very touchy article. God bless your perseverance mission.
    “Justice never dies, it gets sick then recovers”.
    Baruyr Sevag

  10. Just remember one thing and one thing only. The world knows about this destruction historically and turkey will have to answer at some point. These are all documented events of which turkey was counting on towards eradicating our past but instead brought direct attention to themselves.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*