Between Sultan and Ataturk: Erdogan Wins Turkey’s Presidential Race
Aren TorikianAugust 11, 2014Last Updated: August 11, 2014
7 2 minutes read
Erdogan
ANKARA (A.W.)—On Aug. 10, the Republic of Turkey held direct presidential elections for the first time in its 91-year history, won by Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan. Previously, incumbent Abdullah Gul and his ten predecessors had all been elected by Turkey’s Grand National Assembly. The change to a direct vote came after a push by Erdogan, who was also the front-runner coming into the election.
Turkey’s Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan won the country’s first direct presidential election on Aug. 10 (Photo by Nanore Barsoumian, The Armenian Weekly)
Originally from Beirut, Lebanon, Aren Torikian has lived in Lexington, Massachusetts for most of his life. A student at Tufts University, Aren intends to study history and economics. He is currently interning at the Armenian Weekly, as part of the Armenian Students’ Association of America (ASA) internship in journalism program.He is a member of the Greater Boston chapter of the Armenian Youth Federation, and enjoys watching re-runs, namely of Scrubs and The Office.
7 Comments
The options for President were Erdogan, Erdogan v2 with a Phd and ties to the Gulen movement, and a Kurd who is way to liberal and respects human and minority rights too much to ever be elected in a place like Turkey.
Furthermore, I don’t understand why Erdogan is going through all this trouble with the presidency and transferring powers there. He could’ve stayed PM. There’s no constitutional term limit for Prime Ministers, the only thing limiting him was AKP’s own charter which limited his tenure to 3 terms. He could have just changed that. Seems like an uncharacteristic respect for democratic values to abide by those rules.
I read someplace that under the current Turkish constitution, the office of Presidency is only symbolic. Certainly Gul had no power while Erdogan was PM. So if a new PM is selected by AKP (presumably Gul), Erdogan will have no power. Makes no sense.
Erdogan is not the type to just give up power. It has been clear during his tenure since 2003 that he wants total control over every aspect of life in Turkey and to shape it according to his Islamist worldview.
Maybe he will next change the Constitution ?
What is your take on what he is up to.
Presidency has always been symbolic since Turkey had its first democratic elections in 1950. Prior to that, there wasn’t a real democracy so I don’t include that era.
During the first period of Erdogan’s Prime Ministership (until 2007), the President was Ahmet Necdet Sezer, a staunch secularist (who banned women in headscarves from Cankaya). He vetoed a lot of legislation, and though AKP had the vast majority of seats in parliament and could find away around his vetoes, Sezer was a thorn in the side of Erdogan and AKP and it was plainly obvious he greatly disliked Erdogan and Islamists.
So in 2007, Erdogan and AKP thought they solved this problem by putting a yes-man in Cankaya, Abdullah Gul. Though I think its clear in many cases Erdogan and Gul were playing good cop-bad cop, I find Gul to be a little more moderate than Erdogan. At the very least, he has a calmer demeanor and is much more respectful to political opposition. There are also reports, and I’m not sure if they are just rumors or something more, that Erdogan and Gul don’t like each other anymore. I’d be a little surprised if Gul was named PM. I’ve also read that Davutoglu is out of question as well due to his failure as FM. I’ve read that Binali Yildirim may be the next Prime Minister, as he is the textbook definition of a yes-man.
Erdogan wants to change Turkey into a Presidential republic. However, this constitutional change will be hotly contested and will not happen overnight. He needs someone in the PM post that will do everything he says until the change to a presidential republic happens, which presumably it will. Then there will be no question as to whole holds the power.
It’s interesting that both Gulen and Erdogan are religiously inclined as opposed to being ‘secular’, but are also opposed to one another. I suppose Erdogan accuses Gulen of being an American shill, but recent audio leaks proved that so is Erdogan, although I don’t know if Erdogan has plans to change that.
And with – “is way to liberal and respects human and minority rights too much to ever be elected in a place like Turkey.” – I think you pretty much summed up all that is wrong with Turkey.
As I wrote on my fbk today, just another Turk with great ambition of power, we Armenians know how that can end….ask Tallat Pasha
so the question is does the world at this sensible time need another tirant and dictator? I think not, and by the way, there goes any chance for turkish centennial recognition of any kind of Genocide, least of the Armenian.
Arthur, How could you say Tyrant and dictator ? He was elected with a majority in a free and fair election, it is a functional democracy, not like in North Korea where Kim junior gets a 99.99% vote
Any news about Erdogan’s position towards Armenia and Armenia’s position towards him?.
The options for President were Erdogan, Erdogan v2 with a Phd and ties to the Gulen movement, and a Kurd who is way to liberal and respects human and minority rights too much to ever be elected in a place like Turkey.
Furthermore, I don’t understand why Erdogan is going through all this trouble with the presidency and transferring powers there. He could’ve stayed PM. There’s no constitutional term limit for Prime Ministers, the only thing limiting him was AKP’s own charter which limited his tenure to 3 terms. He could have just changed that. Seems like an uncharacteristic respect for democratic values to abide by those rules.
I read someplace that under the current Turkish constitution, the office of Presidency is only symbolic. Certainly Gul had no power while Erdogan was PM. So if a new PM is selected by AKP (presumably Gul), Erdogan will have no power. Makes no sense.
Erdogan is not the type to just give up power. It has been clear during his tenure since 2003 that he wants total control over every aspect of life in Turkey and to shape it according to his Islamist worldview.
Maybe he will next change the Constitution ?
What is your take on what he is up to.
Presidency has always been symbolic since Turkey had its first democratic elections in 1950. Prior to that, there wasn’t a real democracy so I don’t include that era.
During the first period of Erdogan’s Prime Ministership (until 2007), the President was Ahmet Necdet Sezer, a staunch secularist (who banned women in headscarves from Cankaya). He vetoed a lot of legislation, and though AKP had the vast majority of seats in parliament and could find away around his vetoes, Sezer was a thorn in the side of Erdogan and AKP and it was plainly obvious he greatly disliked Erdogan and Islamists.
So in 2007, Erdogan and AKP thought they solved this problem by putting a yes-man in Cankaya, Abdullah Gul. Though I think its clear in many cases Erdogan and Gul were playing good cop-bad cop, I find Gul to be a little more moderate than Erdogan. At the very least, he has a calmer demeanor and is much more respectful to political opposition. There are also reports, and I’m not sure if they are just rumors or something more, that Erdogan and Gul don’t like each other anymore. I’d be a little surprised if Gul was named PM. I’ve also read that Davutoglu is out of question as well due to his failure as FM. I’ve read that Binali Yildirim may be the next Prime Minister, as he is the textbook definition of a yes-man.
Erdogan wants to change Turkey into a Presidential republic. However, this constitutional change will be hotly contested and will not happen overnight. He needs someone in the PM post that will do everything he says until the change to a presidential republic happens, which presumably it will. Then there will be no question as to whole holds the power.
It’s interesting that both Gulen and Erdogan are religiously inclined as opposed to being ‘secular’, but are also opposed to one another. I suppose Erdogan accuses Gulen of being an American shill, but recent audio leaks proved that so is Erdogan, although I don’t know if Erdogan has plans to change that.
And with – “is way to liberal and respects human and minority rights too much to ever be elected in a place like Turkey.” – I think you pretty much summed up all that is wrong with Turkey.
As I wrote on my fbk today, just another Turk with great ambition of power, we Armenians know how that can end….ask Tallat Pasha
so the question is does the world at this sensible time need another tirant and dictator? I think not, and by the way, there goes any chance for turkish centennial recognition of any kind of Genocide, least of the Armenian.
Arthur, How could you say Tyrant and dictator ? He was elected with a majority in a free and fair election, it is a functional democracy, not like in North Korea where Kim junior gets a 99.99% vote
Any news about Erdogan’s position towards Armenia and Armenia’s position towards him?.