Podcasts

PODCAST: Exploring the Gray Area in Armenian Politics

Already a subscriber?Log in here

This story is FREE for you...

Create a free account to access this and four more articles, and get more sent to you with our e-newsletter.

Or, subscribe now for unlimited access
By submitting your email address you agree for Hairenik Association, Inc. to send you communication by email.

Karine Vann

Karine Vann is a former editor of the Armenian Weekly. A musician who was deeply affected by the poverty and environmental degradation she observed living in Armenia from 2014 to 2017, she now covers topics at the intersection of consumerism and the environment for local and national publications as a journalist. In addition to writing for the Weekly, her work has appeared in Dig Boston, The Counter, Civil Eats and Waste Dive. To supplement her writing, she has worked in jobs traversing the Greater Boston area's food economy, from farming to fair trade spices. She lives in Cambridge with her husband and anxious beagle, Rasa.

10 Comments

  1. Concerning Sanamyan’s idea that “… power is basically concentrated … in one man’s hands, in Nikol Pashinyan’s hands…”
    Yes, it would be nice “creating a competitive system, where it’s not just about one person or one force that knows everything and moves the country forward…”
    But reality and some “South Caucasus specific” come into conflict with these wishes in the near future…
    There is very little likelihood of creating “such a system” in a single state in this “very” regional geopolitical environment… in the short term.
    …
    Unfortunately — Armenians, Azerbaijanis and Georgians (Abkhazians and Ossetians) can not find the clue to sustain peaceful co-existence without some power—“be that Russia or the West—coming in and imposing total control there. That’s the challenge that’s still unmet.”

    I like Emil Sanamyan’s idea regarding RA (Armenia) and Diaspora (Spyurk). As a citizen of Georgia of course “if you look at it critically, Diaspora and Armenia are in a contentious relationship…” … not to mention the relationship between RA and RF’s Spyurk (Russian Federation)…

    Interview was interesting. Thanks.

    1. As a “neutral” Westerner who has chosen to settle in Armenia I greatly appreciate this kind of article. I’m just beginning to learn about the history of this region and all detailed subtle analyses are more than welcome.
      If anyone out there is interested in my impressions and comments as a non-Armenian immigrant I’ll be more than happy to share them.
      Mike K.

  2. There was no Azerbaijan before 1918.

    It’s a made-up country. That de-legitimizes a lot of its claims.

    If Armenia was a made-up country, I suspect that a lot of nicey-nicey Armenians, perhaps including Mr. Sanamyan, would be saying, “Oh, look, let’s admit Armenia did not even exist before 1918 so let’s not make too many claims. Azerbaijan is ancient and should take precedence.”

    I am disappointed that Mr. Sanamyan did not mention that over time Azerbaijan denuded Nakhichevan of Armenians and was doing the same to Artsakh.

    It’s all well and good to be nicey-nicey and kind-and-gentle about this, but I don’t buy it.

    Ottoman Turkey joined hands with Azeris in WW 1 and tried to destroy Armenia. They are trying again. Mr. Sanamyan did not mention this either.

    1. Justice is gained by the sword. That which is lost to the sword has to be regained by the sword. Two hundred years ago, the Various Mongol, Tatar, Turkic tribes overwhelmed the natives, now the natives are taking back some of that land. Well, that’s the way it is.

  3. An interesting interview that provides a different perspective.
    Cannot agree with all the opinions/answers expressed by Sanamyan, specifically about how Artsakh was annexed to Azerbaijan. It was unjust.
    Also,the area under Soviet rule was “peaceful” because no dissent was allowed, and anyone who opposed the regime either ended up in Siberia, rotted in jail or was killed.
    Vart Adjemian

  4. In terms of the former Azerbaijani residents of Armenia and Artsakh, I don’t disagree that it must have been painful for them to have been forced to leave their homes; however, you cannot possibly blame the Armenians for this. After all, it was the Azerbaijanis who began that whole mess by committing massacres against Armenians in the cities of Sumgait, Kirovabad, and Baku. The Azerbaijanis’ ultimate aim was to commit a genocide against the Armenian population of Azerbaijan, who barely managed to escape from that country. All of this, ultimately, started the war over Artsakh. Therefore, as a result of all this, it was just not possible for the former Azerbaijani residents of Armenia and Artsakh to remain over there.

    In terms of Agdam, it was indeed a part of the historic Armenian province of Artsakh. Furthermore, the whole entire Artsakh Republic falls within the boundaries of historic Artsakh; therefore, no single part of the Artsakh Republic happens to be a “occupied Azerbaijani territory.” As a matter of fact, the area of historic Artsakh consisted of 15,000 square kilometers, which was 3,500 square kilometers more than the area of today’s Artsakh Republic. Those remaining 3,500 square kilometers are represented by the three remaining territories of Artsakh, which are currently occupied by Azerbaijan. Besides Artsakh, there are also two other historic Armenian provinces (Utik and Paytarakan) located at the very eastern end of the Armenian Plateau, which are also under the occupation of Azerbaijan.

    In terms of how Artsakh ended up becoming annexed to Azerbaijan, not many people are aware that after the establishment of Soviet rule in Armenia, the Bolshevik leadership of Azerbaijan had actually declared the “disputed territories” (which consisted of Artsakh, Zangezur, and Nakhichevan) as being inseparable parts of Armenia. Soviet Russia, along with the international community welcomed this act; and as a result, a resolution was adopted in the League of Nations Assembly in March of 1921. However, a short while later, the leadership of Soviet Russia (Joseph Stalin), reversed its policy on the “disputed territories.” The Azerbaijanis, following Stalin’s orders, renewed their claims on Artsakh and Nakhichevan. In violation of the decision of the League of Nations, Joseph Stalin detached the provinces of Artsakh and Nakhichevan from Soviet Armenia, and annexed both of them to Soviet Azerbaijan.

    Why did Joseph Stalin do all of this against the Armenians? There are two reasons for all of this: first of all, Joseph Stalin hated everything about the Armenian people; therefore, he wanted to deeply hurt Armenia by removing the provinces of Artsakh and Nakhichevan (which he gave away to the Azerbaijanis), as well as removing the province of Javakhk (which he gave away to the Georgians). And the second reason is that by doing all of the above (as well as forcing Armenia to cede Kars, Ardahan, Artvin, Ani, Igdir, Lake Van, and Mount Ararat to the Turks), he foolishly attempted to persuade Turkey to become a Soviet Republic, which the Turks never had any intention of doing in the first place.

  5. Excellent comments by Mr. Yerevanian which I fully agree. I suggest Mr. Emil Sanamyan to carefully study Armenian history before making comments on what is Armenian or not.

  6. Emil, this was a very interesting interview, even for someone like me who has been following you for some years now. You know how much I respect your work, and this insightful piece reinforces my sense that, even if there will always be disagreements about history, ancient and modern, your contribution to the conversation is invaluable. Keep up your good work!

    1. Dear U.S. Ambassador Evans:

      I am so glad that you commented on this interview.

      All Armenians, of course, thank you for your principled acknowledgment of the Armenian Genocide during your tenure in Armenia. Like others, I admire your courage and you and your wife Donna’s ongoing support of Armenia and Artsakh.

      Might you care to briefly answer these questions?

      1) Why is it that, except for Armenia itself, every surrounding country for a radius of perhaps 1000 miles has some kind of link (citizens, land route, bases, supplies, attacks, etc.) with terrorist/jihadists, and yet the US has made virtually no mention of Armenia’s record during our (mostly phony) “War on Terror”?

      2) Why is is that study after study (such as David Phillips’s two Columbia Univ. studies) has proven that Turkey has supported and does support ISIS and various related jihadists, and yet your colleagues in the State and Defense Departments have had little to say about this? Is it because the US itself has supported some ISIS factions and other jihadists in support of, for example, overthrowing Syria’s President Assad?

      3) It is well-known that numerous Jews worldwide, in addition to Israel, are involved in a continuing campaign of slander against Armenia, due in part to Jewish/Israeli support for Azerbaijian. Would you please comment on this slander and the failure of your colleagues in the foreign policy establishment (State Dept., Defense Dept., Council on Foreign Relations, etc.) to address that campaign of slander? Perhaps they like to see Armenian slandered?

      5) Would you please comment on the fact that many top Jewish organizations have long aided Turkey in denial of the Armenian Genocide and in defeating Armenian Genocide resolutions in Congress? Please see my article “Hypocritical Jewish Organizations and the Armenian Genocide:
      https://www.foreignpolicyjournal.com/2019/06/25/hypocritical-jewish-organizations-and-the-armenian-genocide/

      Again, thank you for your courage and principle.

Back to top button