FeaturedSpecial Reports
Scholarship, Manufacturing Doubt, and Genocide Denial

Scholarship, Manufacturing Doubt, and Genocide Denial (1)
The Armenian Weekly April 2013 Magazine
(Download in PDF)

Scholarship, Manufacturing Doubt, and Genocide Denial (1)
The Armenian Weekly April 2013 Magazine
(Download in PDF)
Already a subscriber?Log in here
“Retraction and Apology
In the summer 2008 issue of its Intelligence Report, the Southern Poverty Law Center reported that Guenter Lewy, a professor emeritus at the University of Massachusetts, was part of a network of persons, financed by the Government of Turkey, who dispute that the tragic events of World War I constituted an Armenian genocide. We now realize that we misunderstood Professor Lewy’s scholarship, were wrong to assert that he was part of a network financed by the Turkish Government, and were wrong to assume that any scholar who challenges the Armenian genocide narrative necessarily has been financially compromised by the Government of Turkey. We hereby retract the assertion that Professor Lewy was or is on the Government of Turkey’s payroll.
To our knowledge, Professor Lewy has never sought to deny or minimize the deaths of Armenians in Ottoman Turkey; nor has he sought to minimize the Ottoman regime’s grievous wartime miscalculations or indifference to human misery in a conflict earmarked by widespread civilian suffering on all sides. What he has argued in his book, The Armenian Massacres in Ottoman Turkey: A Disputed Genocide, and elsewhere is that the present historical record does not substantiate a premeditated plan by the Ottoman regime to destroy because of ethnicity, religion, or nationality, as opposed to deport for political-military reasons, the Armenian population. In this view, he is joined by such distinguished scholars as Professor Bernard Lewis of Princeton University. As additional troves of archival information come to light, Professor Lewy advocates greater study of this contentious subject.
We deeply regret our errors and offer our sincerest apologies to Professor Lewy.”
http://legalinsurrection.com/2010/09/splc-to-apologize-to-prof-guenter-lewy-for-false-accusations/
And your point is?
As is well known, Lewy endorsed Turkish scholar Selim Deringil’s conclusions that the Ottoman state committed “‘ colossal crimes'” against the Armenians and that the thesis of mutual combat was indefensible. I guess you disagree, eh Max?
Lewy merely cherry-picked what he claimed were the three chief arguments in favor of the AG thesis, and tried to say they were not persuasive to him. He clearly stated that the issue deserved more study so far as he was concerned, and did not say no genocide took place.
His chief conclusion seemed to be that the triumverate was too stupid and backwards to plan extermination. A ringing endorsement for your friends. Doesn’t do much harm to the work of scholars concerning the Genocidal Governor of Diyarbekir, does it?
If the SPLC inaccurately claimed that Lewy was an agent,that hardly calls into question Mr. Mammagonian’s fascinating and well-wrought thesis. It does not even undermine Lewy’s admissions.
By the way, Max, what do you do when you go to Turkey, and who pays your expenses?
I should add that Derengil is quoted as of 2010 as calling the extermination of Armenians a Genocide, not just a colossal crime.
But of course, Petite Monsieur Maxime here says Non! to the final fiber of his tiny being. He has finally found some Turks to admire him. Playmates at last.
Or, Maxie, why don’t you walk us through what happened to Donald Quataert when he reversed course to conclude in his well known Ottoman text to say the truth – that it was Genocide? You know – the part about the funding drying up and losing his position. That part.
Here are some excerpts from Turkish TodaysZaman article about Mr. Gauin:
[“This website is officially administered by one of our esteemed intelligence officials. Upon our order our employee has gone against the education in history he received and lobbies in favor of the Turks. His education in history strengthens his ties with the Turks. He is now serving as an intern at a nationalist think tank in Ankara. Thanks to his efforts, we learn the working principles of our Turkish colleagues and their attitude toward opponents in France — mainly Armenians and Kurds,” says the report.
Sources told Today’s Zaman on condition of anonymity that the intelligence official in question is historian and researcher Maxime Gauin, who has written books against Armenian claims of genocide. He is currently an intern at the International Strategic Research Organization (USAK) in Ankara. Gauin earlier won a compensation case he filed against Movses Nisanyan, a member of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation, who had accused him of being a collaborator of the “genocide.”]
[….Sources told Today’s Zaman that the report is authentic. The report has a fourth level of confidentiality, which is restricted distribution.]
Quite interesting then that Mr. Gauin – who has denied the TZ statements and who is not shy about suing for libel and defamation – has not sued Turkish TodaysZaman for libel and defamation.
Inquiring minds want to know the reason: maybe the reason is that TZ statements are true and Mr. Gauin is afraid the truth will come out in a court of law under cross examination.
—-
We would also like to know why Mr. Gauin-oglu has not responded to the email of his denialist brother Mr. Ragnar Naess, who asked Gauin-oglu to explain his manufactured forgery about supposed little Qurans supposedly found on supposed Muslims skeletons: said forgery was being disseminated on the pages of ArmenianWeekly by Mr. Gauin-oglu.
Last posting by Mr. Naess indicated Gauin-oglu has not answered his (Naess’s) many private email inquiries regarding the forgery.
Sure it does. The US national archives clearly states “race extermination” as it was happening. Sorry vile, your not changing history. Even if if a few mercenary historians “doubt it” we can lump you with Holocaust deniers..
SPLC president Richard Cohen
“Like you, we believe that the weight of scholarly opinion supports the conclusion that the murder of Armenians during World War I should be characterized as a genocide. We said as much in the article we published in 2008, and nothing in our retraction changes our position. We hope that others do not confuse our retraction and apology to Professor Lewy as an endorsement of his view on the genocide …”
He actually said one thing and its opposite, from one day to the other day. But the most important is that he confessed false and unsubsantiated allegations, and never backed off about this precise point.
The same strategy used by the Tobacco Industry is now being hijacked and implemented on a much grander scale by Big Oil for climate change denial. However, as history attests to human behavior, there is so much misinformation that people will buy before truth prevails; especially in the modern age where free flow of information is prevalent with the advent of the internet and other mediums.
Maxie,
Tell us why you enjoy the applause of ATAA and Mr. Kirlikovali, who has slandered Armenians in print repeatedly. He does not just dispute the AG, but has often made essentialist remarks, such as that the vast majority of Armenians spring from a culture of crime and corruption.
Just like what Uncle Adolf used to say about Jews, Slavs, Turks [he called them Mongrels] Armenians [ he said they were noble Persians defiled by Jews] and… the French.
Why do you help people who think you are an inferior, if useful idiot?
Excellent article, on every level. Powerful and persuasive.
Here’s a (very) quick take on commonalities between the tobacco and Turkey denial lobbies.
http://armenianweekly.com/2012/04/21/hamparian-truth-justice-and-the-armenian-way/
Prof;. Chris Simpson of AU shared this connection during an ANCA-Greater Washington panel discussion at Georgetown some years back (Samantha Power was also on the panel).
I am sorry, I can’t but notice how well Maxime Gauin’s cited letter/retraction fits into the sad paradigm that Mamigonyan has outlined. The following excerpt that outlines Lewy’s position on the Armenian Genocide seems to be a perfect case of ‘doubt creation’: “To our knowledge, Professor Lewy has never sought to deny or minimize the deaths of Armenians in Ottoman Turkey; nor has he sought to minimize the Ottoman regime’s grievous wartime miscalculations or indifference to human misery in a conflict earmarked by widespread civilian suffering on all sides. What he has argued in his book, The Armenian Massacres in Ottoman Turkey: A Disputed Genocide, and elsewhere is that the present historical record does not substantiate a premeditated plan by the Ottoman regime to destroy because of ethnicity, religion, or nationality, as opposed to deport for political-military reasons, the Armenian population. In this view, he is joined by such distinguished scholars as Professor Bernard Lewis of Princeton University.” And PLEASE, do not cite the “prominent” historian Bernard Lewis who has been more than once criticized for his classical orientalist arguments throughout his scholarship. Lewy has done exactly what Mamigonian is saying about those scholars who have endorsed the tobacco companies ‘doubts’ about the relationship of smoking and cancer: inseminate doubts, you still need that one more bit of information because you can be sure. And this should be condemned not ‘apologized’. Can you imagine someone doing this hair-splitting and negation about the Holocaust? I find this type of attitude, especially from a reputable scholar, despicable.
then take a court action if you can dare but I very much doubt that Armenians are brave enough to do that.Why do not you put an end to the Turkish denial by doing that ha?
Just a remark, which should be accepted even from the Dashnak point of view: when you (and others) are making comments on this web site with pen names, the books of Guenter Lewy, Michael M. Gunter and Norman Stone (to quote only three) are sold all over the world.
Mein Kampf is a bestseller in Turkey. Maybe your employer, USAK, gives out free copies to its interns ?
Do you deny Hitler’s magnum opus Mein Kampf is a bestseller in Turkey – denialist Gauinoglu ?
The Nazi blueprint for the extermination of Untermenschen is a best seller in fascist, genocidal Turkey: surprise, surprise.
Bestselling British historian David Irving is also a vile Holocaust Denialist.
Lots of books written by deranged people are bestsellers.
There is a market for everything: some sick people are into Genocide denial, Holocaust denial; you name it, there is probably a sick customer for it.
Very interesting article. What we have here is a good example [“good” here means proving the point] of cognitive warfare. In other words, cogwar is an effort over a long period of time to change and reshape public opinion, beliefs, attitudes, convictions, etc. It is not simple indoctrination that either the tobacco industry or the Turkish state are carrying but a sophisticated cogwar process, endeavor and effort in mass psychology.
By the way, I don’t know if most Armenians are aware that one of those who brought out the most reliable information on the ongoing genocide was the Israeli agronomist Aaron Aaronson, leader of the NILI underground group, that spied on the Ottoman war effort and delivered the info to the British. So the British were well-informed by Aaronson and by other sources. Aaronson’s sister Sarah was an eyewitness to the genocide process, as was his comrade in the NILI group, Eitan Belkind. Belkind left behind an important memoir covering the WW One period, inter alia, but published only in Hebrew. Aaronson has been the subject of several biographies in English which go into his activities regarding the AG and related matters.
Eliyahu,
Yes, this is a powerful piece. I very much appreciate your bringing in Aaron Aaronsohn, his heroic sister Sarah, and the NILI group in general. That chapter of history should never be forgotten. Given a current situation in which so much of the consonance between the fates of Jews and Armenians has been sacrificed to the interests of the crassest power politics, we would all do well to realize the depth of dread that permeated the Jewish communities of Palestine at the news of the unprecedented horrors that were being inflicted on the Armenians to the north. The Aaronsohns indelibly inscribed that moment into history.
Diran, since some folks may be interested, I found some blog posts in English that quote extensively from Eitan Belkind’s account of the Armenian genocide as he saw it:
http://ziontruth.blogspot.co.il/2008/05/activist-zionists-armenian-genocide-in.html
http://ziontruth.blogspot.co.il/2008/05/activist-zionists-armenian-genocide.html
http://ziontruth.blogspot.co.il/2008/07/jews-caught-up-in-armenian-genocide.html
http://ziontruth.blogspot.co.il/2008/07/armenian-genocide-german-role-in-it-as.html
One of the less known facts of that period was that in early 1917, the Ottoman governor ordered the evacuation of the new city of Tel Aviv by its Jewish inhabitants. About 9,000 Jews from Tel Aviv were sent wandering the roads essentially without food. There were many more Jews living in Jerusalem at the time but as far as I know they were not forced to evacuate. Nevertheless, this evacuation was like the preliminary steps in the Armenian genocide.
Yes, thank you Ms. Eliyahu m’Tsiyon.
Very useful links: will add a new dimension to our knowledge base. We will put it to good use countering AG Denialist disinformation.
I am still studying the blogs, but this passage of yours is very revealing:
{Moreover, there are certain Jewish historians and Middle East specialists, in the US, Israel, and France, who argue that there was not an Armenian genocide. Some of these writers are rabid Islamophiles for whom Muslims, whether Turks or Arabs, can do no wrong. }.
—-
There is one infamous example of such an AG Denialist rabid Islamophile French Jew who works for the denialist Turks (USAK): we call him Maxime Gauinoglu. (he is the first guest in this thread, above)
He is very active in spreading AG Denialist disinformation.
He visits us here @AW frequently: he is of course given a warm welcome.
It is refreshing to hear a Jew such as yourself denounce these vile Jewish AG denialists.
We Armenians know of course that many more Jews and Israeli Jews (e.g. Dr Israel Charny) support the truth, but it is disconcerting when victims of the Holocaust, who also have to deal with Holocaust deniers, join forces with AG denialists.
Glad you visited us at ArmenianWeekly.
Thank you, Eliyahu. Thank you for holding up a powerful magnifying glass to that tragic era and bringing the connection between the fates of the two people’s into specific, undeniable focus again. It goes very far to dispel the fog of lies the denialist Turkish state has pumped out for almost a century now to falsify and completely bury the reality of 1915.
Simple: Lump these deniers with Holocaust deniers. Every time. Example “just as there are Holocaust deniers there are Armenian Genocide deniers”.. That simple.
If a genocide denying “scholar” is not on the payroll of the Turkish government, you can bet they are on another one equally vile. Southern Poverty Law Center, Guenter Lewy, Bernard Lewis, just check their backgrounds and you will see who they are. These pseudo-scholar extremists have figured that recognition of the Armenian Genocide will harm the profits and/or impact from the Holocaust money machine, from which they have acquired a blank check to do and say as they please against anyone and anything without any fear of reprisal.
where is Maxie? asking T friends for instructions?
I sense a certain Judeophobic paranoia in Kevork’s screed. Does he forget the contribution that Ambassador Morgenthau, Aaron and Sarah Aaronson and the NILI group made to getting the information about the Armenian genocide out to the Entente Powers –those powers opposing the German, Austro-Hungarian & Ottoman Triple Alliance? How about the contribution of Franz Werfel to keeping the memory of the AG alive through his novel, The Forty Days of Musa Dagh? Guenter Lewy does not represent any Jewish representative organization and his writing is on his own responsibility. Why don’t you complain about his publishers who were, I believe, American university presses? Bernard Lewis does have a lot of prestige, and in Israel too. However, he did not employ his prestige to stop or cancel or minimize the discussion held in the Knesset a few weeks ago –April 23– to commemorate the Armenian genocide. Members of Knesset of parties across the political spectrum spoke about the AG on the occasion of the April 24 anniversary. Zeev Elkin, a leading member of the Likud party [PM Netanyahu’s party] took a special interest the AG. So all that means nothing when weighed against simplistic Judeophobic paranoia.
As to Lewis, he has written a great deal during his long career but little about the Holocaust. I am not aware that he is seeking or has ever sought to make a profit from the Holocaust. Of course, we can and do fault his position on the Armenian Genocide. But to accuse him of trying to make money out of “the Holocaust money machine” is not truthful.
I wanted to add, in response to Kevork and before I forget, the rather lengthy article about the Armenian genocide in Ha-Ummah, the quarterly journal of the Jabotinsky Institute which is close to the Likud party and PM Netanyahu. The article was written as far back as 1947 [Ha-Mashqif, 9-14-1947] and reprinted in Ha-Ummah #186, summer of 2012. The author was Abba Ahimeir whose son Yosef is now editor of Ha-Ummah. It is entitled: “The Slaughter of the Armenians in the war of 1914-1918” [Tevahh ha-Armenim b’Milhemet 1914-1918][טבח הארמנים במלחמת 1918-1914]
Why consider someone’s ethnicity or religion as relevant, including Gauin’s? After all, why stress his Jewishness rather than his Frenchness? And why not ascribe Abdul Hamid’s or Veli Küçük’s crimes to their Armenian genes? We all wish that being a member of a victimized group worked as a vaccine against essentialism, racism, sexism etc but unfortunately it doesn’t work that way. It’s a matter of individual ethical choices : M. Gauin has chosen to hate the survivors of a population that has been decimated (Armenians) as well as a population that is persecuted (Kurds) and it matters to him that this be known. He doesn’t support Turkish democrats, he has no compassion for all the Turkish students and researchers who are sitting in Turkish jails on no charges. A sweet guy indeed. Now as far as logic is concerned, one could ask him what he would tell Hasan Cemal who laid a flower at Yerevan’s genocide memorial, accepted to see the grand-son of his grand-father Cemal Pasa’s executioner and published a book whose cover bears the mention Armenian Genocide. What would he tell Yavuz Baydar who recently published an article entitled “Turkey should recognize the Armenian Genocide” – not “Catastrophe” nor “pain” nor “incidents” nor “events”? Baydar isn’t a yougster, he is an experienced and well-known journalist who must know what he is doing, especially at a time when some prominent colleagues of his have just lost their jobs for similar stands. Gengiz Aktar has also stopped using other expressions and simply says and writes genocide. Even Ahmet Insel signed a letter together with EGAM (European Grassroots Antiracist Movement) which said Genocide. And he is nearly 60. So let’s just understand how a French kid who calls himself a historian and a scholar though he hasn’t passed any of the competitive exams French historians take (Ecole Normale Superieure, Capes, Agregation), who has never submitted a paper about the Armenian genocide to a French history professor, reacts to the fact that two or three thousand ethnic Turks (OK,they weren’t numerous but they did it) gathered on Taksim square to commemorate the genocide and that first-class Turkish journalists with no a say there was a genocide and Turkey must recognize it. Does the little Frenchy claim he knows better than those middle-aged or elderly Turks?
I was busy until recently, that is why I reply to this personal attack only. My paper, written with Pulat Tacar, was published in the “European Journal of International Law”, a journal edited by the Oxford University Press, with the support of the New York University and of the European University Institute. I was asked to do so; I did not ask.
That’s all for the moment. I smile, and will continue to smile.
Correction : “Turkish journalists with no Armenian or Kurdish genes…”
Eliyahu has given a dignified and measured response to Kevork’s unbalanced comment and I appreciate it. You would have to be blind or worse to overlook the merit of the individuals he mentions and their contributions to the truth about 1915. And there are many others he could have mentioned. To regard all that as nothing because of heritage is the worst kind of blindness and an act of moral vandalism.
As for Maxime Gauin, he has made it his profession to remind Armenians of all their faults and all their failures in their struggle to make the Turkish state accountable for 1915; to pour salt in their wounds every chance he gets, as well as to magnify out of all proportion every conceivable doubt about the reality of the Genocide that he can unearth and throw it in their faces. This is how he fights against the “genocide label”. His academic credentials may be slim or nonexistent, but from Ankara’s point of view that is irrelevant. He is as diligent as a bloodhound in his chosen field.
one of the relevant subjects right now, not only for Armenia but for the Middle East generally, is US-Turkey relations, particularly between Erdogan and Obama. Here is one article on that subject, which may be of some help.
http://www.thecommentator.com/article/3545/a_cut_we_can_all_afford
I still have some trouble understanding why Obama feels so close to Erdogan specifically, why Obama promotes Erdogan, who on the surface, at least, usually sounds imbalanced, not all there, besides being full of boastful rodomontade, of bluster that would be even more frightening if he could deliver on it. Here note that more than a year ago Erdung was threatening the EU if Cyprus were allowed to assume its scheduled turn in the rotation of states taking the EU presidency. Of course, the threat against the EU got little attention in the USA where most of the media follow the NYTimes rule: All the news that’s fit to print. We know from experience that a lot of news is not fit to print by NYTimes standards. That is, a lot of news is politically inconvenient. But I’ll keep on trying to figure out Obama’s special attachment to Erdogan.