The seed that finally took root: The kernel that led to ‘The Sandcastle Girls’ By Chris Bohjalian Sometimes my novels have positively elephantine gestation periods—and even that, in some cases, is an underestimate. A mother elephant carries her young for not quite two years; I have spent, in some cases, not quite two decades contemplating the tiniest seed of a story and wondering how it might grow into a novel. Moreover, in the quarter-century I’ve been writing books, I’ve realized two things about a lengthy gestation period. First, the longer I spend allowing an idea to take root inside me, the better the finished book; second, the more time I spend thinking about a book, the less time I spend actually writing it. Here’s a confession: The first draft of the novel for which I may always be known best, Midwives, took a mere (and eerily appropriate) nine months to write. Skeletons at the Feast, another book I will always be proud of, took only 10. But I spent a long time pondering both of these novels before ever setting a single word down on paper. Perhaps in no case has the relationship between reflection and construction—between the ethereal wisps of imagination and the concrete words of creation—been more evident than in the novel I have arriving this summer, The Sandcastle Girls. The novel has been gestating at the very least since 1992, when I first tried to make sense of the Armenian Genocide: a slaughter that most of the world knows next to nothing about. My first attempt to write about the genocide, penned 20 years ago now, exists only as a rough draft in the underground archives of my alma mater. It will never be published, neither in my lifetime nor after I’m dead. I spent over two years struggling mightily to complete a draft, and I never shared it with my editor. My wife, who has always been an objective reader of my work, and I agreed: The manuscript should either be buried or burned. I couldn’t bring myself to do either, but neither did I ever want the pages to see the light of the day. Hence, the exile to the underground archives. Moreover, just about this time, Carol Edgarian published her poignant drama of the Armenian Genocide and the diaspora, Rise the Euphrates. It’s a deeply moving novel and, it seemed to me, a further indication that the world didn’t need my book. And so instead I embarked upon a novel that had been in the back of my mind for some time: A tale of a New England midwife and a home birth that has gone tragically wrong. Over the next 15 years, all but one of my novels would be set largely in New England. Sometimes they would be about women and men at the social margins: homeopaths, transsexuals, and dowsers. Other times they would plumb social issues that matter to me: homelessness, domestic violence, and animal rights. The one exception, the one book not set in New England? Skeletons at the Feast, a story set in Poland and Germany in the last six months of the Second World War. That novel is, in part, about a fictional family’s complicity in the Holocaust. Often as I toured on behalf of the book in 2008 and 2009, readers would ask me the following: When was I going to write about the Armenian Genocide? After all, from my last name it’s clear that I am at least part Armenian. (I am, in fact, half-Armenian; my mother was Swedish.) I had contemplated the subject often, even after failing in my first attempt to build a novel around the Meds Yeghern. The Great Calamity. Three of my four Armenian great-grandparents died in the poisonous miasma of the genocide and the First World War. Moreover, some of my best—and from a novelist’s perspective most interesting—childhood memories occurred while I was visiting my Armenian grandparents at their massive brick monolith of a home in a suburb of New York City. Occasionally, my Mid-Western, Swedish mother would refer to their house as the “Ottoman annex of the Metropolitan,” because it was—at least by the standards of Westchester County in the middle third of the twentieth century—so exotic. In 2010, my father’s health began to deteriorate badly. He lived in Florida at the time, while I lived in Vermont. I remember how on one of my visits, when he was newly home after yet another long stay in the hospital, together we looked at old family photographs. I was trying to take his mind off his pain, but I also found the exercise incredibly interesting. In some cases, these were images I had seen on the walls of my grandparents’ or my parents’ house since I was a child, but they had become little more than white noise: I knew them so well that I barely noticed them and they had grown as invisible to me as old wallpaper. Now, however, they took on a new life. I recall one in particular that fascinated me: a formal portrait of my father when he was five years old, his parents behind him. All of them are impeccably coiffed. My grandfather is seated in an elegant wooden chair in the sort of suit and tie and vest that he seemed always to be wearing when I was a boy, and my grandmother is standing beside him in a beautiful black dress with a white collar and a corsage. I can see bits of my daughter—their great-granddaughter—in my grandmother’s beautiful, almond-shaped eyes. My father, a kindergartener at the time, is wearing shorts, a white shirt, and a rather badly knotted necktie with a cross on it. I knew almost nothing about my grandparents’ story. But that picture reminded me of those moments when, as a child myself, I would sit on my grandfather’s lap or listen to him, enrapt, as he played his beloved oud. I recalled the wondrous aroma of lamb and mint that always wafted from their front door when I would arrive, and my grandmother’s magnificent cheese boregs. I thought of their library filled with books in a language—an alphabet—I could not begin to decipher, even as I was learning to read English. And at some point, the seeds of my family’s own personal diaspora began to take root. I had no interest in revisiting the disastrous manuscript that was gathering dust in my college archives. But I knew that I wanted to try once again to write about the Armenian Genocide. A good friend of mine, a journalist and genocide scholar, urged me on. Ironically, I was about 90 pages into my new book when Mark Mustian published his beautifully written and deeply thought-provoking novel, The Gendarme. I felt a bit as I had in 1994 when I read Carol Edgarian’s Rise the Euphrates. Did the world really need my book when it had Mark’s—or, for that matter, the stories and memoirs that Peter Balakian, Nancy Kricorian, Micheline Aharonian Marcom, and Franz Werfel had given us? It might have been my father’s failing health, or it might have been the fact that I was older now; it might have been the reality that already I cared deeply for the fictional women and men in my new novel. But this time I soldiered on. I think The Sandcastle Girls may be the most important book I’ve written. It is certainly the most personal. It’s a big, broad, sweeping historical love story. The novel moves back and forth in time between the present and 1915; between the narrative of an Armenian-American novelist at mid-life and her grandparents’ nightmarish stories of survival in Aleppo, Van, and Gallipoli in 1915. Those fictional grandparents are not by any stretch my grandparents, but the novel would not exist without their courage and charisma. Is the novel among my best work? The book opens with memories from my childhood in my grandparents’ home, what my mother referred to as the Ottoman Annex. In other words, it has been gestating almost my entire life. Chris Bohjalian’s novel of the Armenian Genocide, The Sandcastle Girls, arrives on July 17.
The Armenian Weekly Magazine
April 2012
Sometimes my novels have positively elephantine gestation periods—and even that, in some cases, is an underestimate. A mother elephant carries her young for not quite two years; I have spent, in some cases, not quite two decades contemplating the tiniest seed of a story and wondering how it might grow into a novel.
[caption id="attachment_18994" align="alignleft" width="197" caption="Chris Bohjalian’s novel of the Armenian Genocide, The Sandcast
Chris Bohjalian is the #1 New York Times bestselling author of 26 books. His latest novel, The Amateur, will be published in August. Bohjalian’s work has been translated into 35 languages and adapted into three films—Midwives, Secrets of Eden and Past the Bleachers—as well as the Emmy-winning television series The Flight Attendant, and two of his other novels are currently in development for television. In addition to his fiction, Bohjalian is also a playwright, with stage works including The Club (2024), Midwives (2020) and Grounded (now Wingspan) (2018).
7 Comments
I look forward to reading ‘The Sandcastle Girls’. I’m an aspiring novelist myself, though I prefer to write speculative fiction I’m also writing a novel about the genocide for my MFA thesis. I’d say there can never be enough stories about it. Every victim had their own story.
There is always room for one more book about the Armenian Genocide, especially one in which feelings and auras about a time past can be recounted for those of us who experienced life with immigrant grandparents and also for those who have no clue about the Armenians and what they have suffered. Kudos to you for not giving up on your idea.
Thank you, Chris Bohjalian, for making the right decision on writing this book about the Armenian Genocide. I agree with the previous two comments. Each time I look at the New Yorker’s booklist and I see yet another book on the Holocaust I think that we can NEVER have enough books on the Genocide. I also think that none of our books will ever reach the general public as the Holocaust books do.
But you are the exception. Hopefully other writers will see why also and follow through too.
Your writing is so creative and captiviating that I myself with Skeletons in the Closet was entralled until the end. Simply beautiful.
I am very much looking forward to the new book.
As a fellow Armenian-American, I thank you.
Sandcastle girls was one of my favorite books that you wrote. I was told about it by an Armenian friend of mine. Since then I read all of your books and am waiting for your new book in July. You are my favorite writer.
I have just started reading sandcastle girls and on page 34 I spotted something that posed a question for me. Ryan Martin raised in Paulding OH. Is this a real person ? I am past president of of our historical soc. and this peeked my interest. Les
My grandparents were born and lived in Aleppo and surrounds, until they migrated to America in 1912. I cannot recall every hearing of them or my father speak of the Armenian Genocide, so your Sandcastle Girls has been enlightening.
Thank you for this moving and informative work.
I look forward to reading ‘The Sandcastle Girls’. I’m an aspiring novelist myself, though I prefer to write speculative fiction I’m also writing a novel about the genocide for my MFA thesis. I’d say there can never be enough stories about it. Every victim had their own story.
There is always room for one more book about the Armenian Genocide, especially one in which feelings and auras about a time past can be recounted for those of us who experienced life with immigrant grandparents and also for those who have no clue about the Armenians and what they have suffered. Kudos to you for not giving up on your idea.
Thank you, Chris Bohjalian, for making the right decision on writing this book about the Armenian Genocide. I agree with the previous two comments. Each time I look at the New Yorker’s booklist and I see yet another book on the Holocaust I think that we can NEVER have enough books on the Genocide. I also think that none of our books will ever reach the general public as the Holocaust books do.
But you are the exception. Hopefully other writers will see why also and follow through too.
Your writing is so creative and captiviating that I myself with Skeletons in the Closet was entralled until the end. Simply beautiful.
I am very much looking forward to the new book.
As a fellow Armenian-American, I thank you.
Please excuse the previous error. I meant to say, “Skeletons at the Feast”.
Sandcastle girls was one of my favorite books that you wrote. I was told about it by an Armenian friend of mine. Since then I read all of your books and am waiting for your new book in July. You are my favorite writer.
I have just started reading sandcastle girls and on page 34 I spotted something that posed a question for me. Ryan Martin raised in Paulding OH. Is this a real person ? I am past president of of our historical soc. and this peeked my interest. Les
My grandparents were born and lived in Aleppo and surrounds, until they migrated to America in 1912. I cannot recall every hearing of them or my father speak of the Armenian Genocide, so your Sandcastle Girls has been enlightening.
Thank you for this moving and informative work.