These are surreal times for the valiant Armenian nation. We are experiencing the trauma of our grandparents with similar atrocities, deportations and territorial loss that our survivor generation carried into the diaspora. The depopulation of an entire enclave in the 21st century has been broadcast on Twitter, Instagram and Facebook. Before continuing, let me say that I abhor the patronizing terms that our world has created to explain what is happening in Artsakh. When I read “forced evacuations,” it describes vacating due to a natural disaster such as wildfires and hurricanes. This is not what our brave people have experienced. It is called a DEPORTATION, and it is component of genocide.




Divisions based on egos occur at the local level in parishes and communities. Yes , forgiveness, Christian charity and self interest would go some ways to healing them. Unfortunately, the real source of divisions in the Armenian world have deeper roots and causes and we see them playing out even in the current crisis. The unresolved question since 1918 has been; “ can Armenia be an independent country?” . One camp believes that Armenia’s destiny is to be a vassal state of Russia. The other camp believes that Armenia can be independent with its own economy, foreign policy and military. This conflict has played out since 1918 and has gone back and forth, with consequential divisions in the diaspora. Unfortunately, the elites in Armenia, Russia and Diaspora have not been able to develop a consensus answer. I think that it would be very helpful to have an honest discussion on the Kocharyan/Sargsyan regime from 1998 to 2018 and compare it with the Pashinyan regime 2018 to 2023. Can we go past accusations of “traitor” and “corruption” and have an intelligent and honest analysis? The future of Armenia may depend on it. If one believe that Armenia can be independent then Armenia needs a world class military to sustain it; its economy and diplomacy supports an independent Armenia. However if one believes that Armenia cannot defend itself ( its economy is too small, geographically isolated, enemies too powerful ) then it becomes subservient to the local powers Russia, Turkey and Iran. But in that scenario it must be prepared to sacrifice territory if the local hegemon demands it. These are difficult issues to discuss honestly but it may help towards reducing divisions in Armenia and diaspora.