YEREVAN—Armenians will be heading back to the polls on April 5 to vote on a proposed amendment to Article 213 of the Armenian Constitution. If successful, the referendum would pave the way for the dismissal of seven of the nine judges currently serving in the Constitutional Court.
Already a subscriber?Log in here
This story is FREE for you...
Create a
free account to access this and four more articles, and get more sent to you with our e-newsletter.
Or, subscribe now for unlimited access
By submitting your email address you agree for Hairenik Association, Inc. to send you communication by email.
This is a great summary! However, it’s not just a minimum turnout of 25% that is required. A minimum of 25% of all eligible voters need to vote “Yes”.
Overall good summary but I’ll add a few precisions and my personal (100% subjective) thoughts (we’re in the comments section after all).
“… shield figures linked to the previous regime from prosecution – most notably former presidents Robert Kocharyan and Serzh Sargsyan”.
The constitutional court (CC) gave its opinion on the R. Kocharyan (RK) case last September. It wasn’t in line with the official stance/wish of the government and the latter immediately blamed the CC of being an RK (and/or SS) lackey and serving the interests of the previous regime. Basically, the CC’s independent stance opposing the mainstream mood in the country is interpreted as selling-off to the previous regime. The result is the lowering of the level of political debate in the country to the cushy/populist level (for the current gov.) of Us vs. Them, Good vs. Bad, New vs. Old (not to mention the Black vs. White … which – in the absence of an African-Armenian community – is luckily not a sensitive topic in Armenia ). Note that this is not done by ordinary voters but by the legislative and executive branches, both full of people supposed to have the political maturity to run a country.
“… Tovmasyan played an instrumental role in drafting the 2015 Constitutional amendment which has long been suspected (and later substantiated) of being a ploy to extend President Sargsyan’s hold on power beyond constitutional limits”.
The suspicion was confirmed as SS decided to remain head of the executive with the new constitution despite his promise to the contrary. Moreover, even if SS had not remained Premier, the RPA could have perpetuated its rule by presenting other candidates from within. The constitution did therefore allow the continuance of power by a political party … but only if the latter derived its authority from democratic processes (i.e. was victorious in elections). It is thus not fair to blame the constitution (or its author HT) for the political machinations of RPA (SS becoming PM using the constitution as excuse) or the political immaturity of the average Armenian voter (giving RPA a majority in 2017). Moreover, whether we agree or not with the spirit/tenets of this constitution (ex. 2 rounds of voting in order to obtain a parliament dominated with a solid 70% majority of any party is in my view a good thing for a country at war), let’s not forget it was pre-validated buy the Venice Commission (VC), the independent European advisory body specialized on all matters pertaining to constitutions.
I could go on but let’s (start to) conclude. In my view, the fact that the current executive and legislative are spending huge political capital and resources and have made an utmost priority to replace the CC with one that has no common past with the previous regime cannot be explained by solely altruistic and patriotic motives i.e. “fight against corruption” or “fight against the previous thieves” (how the CC or HT constitute an obstacle in the path to fighting corruption is beyond me). Moreover, the fact this is being done in a rush (not waiting for next regular elections, skipping the opinion of the CC and that of the VC) and at any cost (calling 2.5 million people to vote on a highly specialized legal matter whereas most Armenian citizens are unaware of the existence of the CC), is pointing to something bigger. Here are examples of situations when the stance/opinion of the CC is required: (1) if the country must undergo territorial or population changes/adjustments (think Artsakh, Meghri or Lachin corridor, resettlement of refugees, etc), (2) if the country is ceding (or taking back) part of its sovereignty to/from a pan-national body (think Eurasian Union, European Union, presence of foreign troops/peacekeepers, etc), (3) if there is a need to evaluate the legitimacy/constitutionality of a vote/referendum to be conducted on a key national issue (think foreign policy, self-determination, Armenian citizens giving their opinion on an Artsakh peace plan, etc).
It is no secret that the previous and present governments don’t have the same approach to the Artsakh issue, with different red lines on key issues related to settlement stages, the acceptability and scope of concessions, etc. Prime minister NP has managed to remain elusive on this most crucial of matters for almost 2 years by mostly throwing generalities like (1) Artsakh must participate in negotiations, (2) Artsakh is Armenia, (3) or the solution must be acceptable to the 3 people. Although he has remained vague on the topic, we know from his previous work as newspaper editor and as a solid LTP ally in 2008 that he does not share the RK/SS perspective on Artsakh. I have the impression that there is deep caution/evasiveness on the matter of Artsakh from the current executive in order to avoid triggering political turmoil within the country on this extremely sensitive issue (going so far as to create permanent turmoil on endless mundane issues to mask this one) which had previously led to the resignation of a president openly backing an unpopular peace initiative.
HT, as a former RPA member – and therefore ideologically in line with the approach of RK and SS on the Artsakh issue – could become a wild card in the hands of factions opposed to an eventual peace plan on Artsakh presented by the government of NP and which would require a green light from the CC at some point during the process. To sum it up, the current government doesn’t want to take chances and wants the CC to fully have its back before serious and non-standard moves are made on the foreign policy front. The same can be said about the new president of Artsakh, to be elected in about a month and widely expected/hoped to share Yerevan’s (to be announced) stance on the Artsakh issue.
One might get the impression that I’m critical/dismissive/blaming NP’s team for this approach as some do, calling them traitors/backstabbers … not at all and quite the contrary. I hope their plan is on those lines … instead of the populistically announced “fight against corruption” or the promises to bring back “Sashik’s 50%” and “Rob’s 4 Billion”. I trust NP and Zohrab Mnatsakanyan with patriotic, well-calculated, and intelligent initiatives aiming to remove this 30 year old Damocles sword from Armenia’s neck. Even if most Armenians end-up disagreeing with the eventual peace plan presented by NP, at least we’ll be reassured to have a government whose imagination/intellect goes beyond pledges to return “Sashik’s 50%”.
My only worry concerns the lack of existing consensus/unity and the level of political polarization in Armenia today, it’s the only element where I find NP to be at fault and responsible.
@Wild Card
Many of the points you bring up are contingent on the glaring paradox at the heart of this issue: If the person heading the Constitutional body with the sole authority to rule on the constitutionality of own its appointments — also happens to have personally authored the constitutional amendment that led to his own appointment at the head of said constitutional body — just how legitimate can this court be?
And I think the answer at the moment is: nobody really knows.
I can certainly understand how the government may outwardly look to be motivated by intolerance for the CC’s independence but it’s not so cut and dry. If I’m not mistaken, 6 out of the 9 CC judges owe their current positions Kocharyan of Sargsyan. Justice Tovmasyan’s close ties to Serzh Sargsyan are well known: having served under him as Minister of Justice, and a long-time senior RPA member. But Tovmasyan also happens to be the the godfather of Kocharyan’s chief attorney Aram Orbelyan – a fact that Tovmasyan never disclosed before. Even stranger is that he never even considered abstaining himself from ruling on the case of his godson’s client…
So is any of this proof that Tovmasyan & co are abusing the powers of the Constitutional Court to protect their allies? — I can’t say — but there is certainly an ABSURD conflict of interest at play here which makes it difficult to believe that this is just a straightforward case of the court judgement differing from the government’s hopes…
So why is so much political capital being expended on this one issue? — because the successful implementation of literally every future policy reform are contingent on the outcome of Judicial reform.
At least some of the hysteria surrounding the referendum seems to stem from the (inaccurate) perception that the amendments “came out of the blue” before being rushed to a vote. In reality, the Gov had announced the planned reforms as soon as it took office. An expert committee (which includes opposition lawmakers) was been drafting the judicial reform package since last year with full cooperation with the Council of Europe.
https://www.coe.int/en/web/yerevan/support-to-the-judicial-reform-enhancing-the-independence-and-professionalism-of-the-judiciary-in-armenia
https://www.venice.coe.int/webforms/documents/default.aspx?pdf=CDL-AD(2019)024-e&lang=en
One more thing to consider: too many people seem concerned that the proposed reform would somehow compromise the CC’s position as an independent body…So let’s be clear: Armenia’s CC has NEVER acted as an independent body. The CC has always acted to rubber stamp decisions by previous governments, and approved self-serving constitutional amendments on 4 previous occasions.
So: the need for this reform isn’t actually in question – The best case scenario that we should hope for is that the amendment succeeds in creating a truly independent judiciary. The worst case scenario? – more of the same.
Thanks Raffi for a true and honest report on this very important issue.
This is an ill-conceived referendum and extremely divisive.
There will be no winners. Lose-Lose on both sides.
A “yes” vote will put an end to the independence of the Judiciary.
A “no” vote will further endanger the possibility of any unity or common purpose; the divide will widen to the detriment of the country.
A very sad and unhealthy situation.
Vart Adjemian
I’m not sure I understand why so many people are worried about the judicial system “losing its independence”. You can’t lose what you never had. Armenia’s CC has historically been notorious for always rubber-stamping the government’s decisions (Which also happened to appoint its members – how fun is that).
Here is what the 2016 Business Anti-Corruption Report says about Armenia’s court system under the RPA:
“The judiciary presents businesses with a high risk of corruption. Bribes and irregular payments are often exchanged to obtain favorable court decisions. The system is not independent: it is subordinate to elites, undermined by corruption, and a lack of training has resulted in a general incompetence of staff. In effect, manipulation of judges by the executive and widespread bribery and inefficiency are major concerns. More than two-thirds of citizens perceive the judiciary to be corrupt”
As I wrote in a previous comment: There is no question that the need for judicial reform is urgent. The question is implementation. So best case scenario: the amendment package serves as the catalyst to finally build a truly independent and robust judiciary branch with the power to tackle corruption. Worst case scenario? — what we’re already living with right now.
Overall, a good read. However, there is a little misinformation.
The author writes, “Following the vote, the Bright Armenia Party held a press conference where leader Edmon Marukyan….. announced his party’s decision to abstain from exercising their right to challenge it in court. ”
This is not true. In fact, Edmon Marukyan reiterated his readiness to challenge the decision in court, provided they got the necessary support of 10 MPs, as mandated by law. A total of 27 MPs was required to challenge the decision in court, Bright Armenia faction has only 17, so 10 more were needed. The reason why Bright Armenia did not challenge was because of the fact that the minimum requirement was not met, unlike what the author describes as “..party’s decision to abstain from their right to challenge it in court.”
An objective summary of a development that is bound to be a watershed moment of the third republic. Well done Raffi and Armenian Weekly keeping the readers informed with such a truly a good reporting.