Opinion

Mensoian: Where Is the ARF of Our Fathers? (Part II)

Part I provided a brief summary of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation’s (ARF) exemplary service to the Armenian people and the interest of the Armenian nation during its first 100 years. Period I: 1890-1923 covered the years from the founding of the ARF to the cataclysmic year of 1923. Period II: 1923-1991 coincided with the catastrophic after effects of the genocide and the existence of the Bolshevik Armenian republic to the founding of the second free Armenian Republic. Part II will assess the role of the ARF during the years following the establishment of the Republic of Armenia in 1991, when its operation moved from the diaspora to the homeland.

Already a subscriber?Log in here

This story is FREE for you...

Create a free account to access this and four more articles, and get more sent to you with our e-newsletter.

Or, subscribe now for unlimited access
By submitting your email address you agree for Hairenik Association, Inc. to send you communication by email.

Michael Mensoian

Michael Mensoian, J.D./Ph.D, is professor emeritus in Middle East and political geography at the University of Massachusetts, Boston, and a retired major in the U.S. army. He writes regularly for the Armenian Weekly.

5 Comments

  1.  A very insightful assessment of the recent period. It is ironic that the ARF had to transition from an indigenous organization to a builder of the diaspora in the early 1920s. It was difficult transition from a geographic,infrastructure and mission perspective. They operated internationally but the core of the organization was the local gomideh driving the establishment and development of what we call our communities today. The ARF essentially reversed that process in the early 1990’s with the exception that they added a presence in Armenia in addition to the diaspora.
           The foreign policy issues that motivate the diaspora is of less concern to the citizens of Armenia. It is comparable to how we behave as Americans politically behave…essentially focused on economics and domestic society as a priority.  This is difficult for us to understand in the diaspora, but it is more important for political parties to have a strategy on jobs, the economy and the quality of life as compared to foreign policy matters that are more removed from day to day life. How do we feel in our current homes about unemployment, corruption and society? It is consistently a higher priority in voting patterns.
            The retention of the population and the talent of Armenia is THE national security issue for our political parties. The ARF must address this in order to be rewarded with more popular support. I have always felt that the ARF was at its best in history as a populist based organization that was more focused on the needs of its constituency….. be that our villagers in the early 20th century, defending the population from the Turkish onslaught during the genocide, the heroic Sadarabad, Karakilise and Bash Abaran, organizing the survivors of the diaspora into a functioning community, defending the rights of our people in Karabagh and advocating for western Armenia.
             Today Armenia need that populist ARF to rebuilt the confidence of the people in their society and to reestablish hope. Our grandfathers did this with selfless sacrifice and a subordination of personal goals. Our history is filled with examples of focused commitment overcoming obstacles. The door is open for the next example in today’s Armenia.

  2. Undoubtedly, this is one of the best, most thoughtful and well articulated articles that appeared in the Armenian Weekly. I sincerely hope that the members of the ARF Bureau read it , get the message, and make a sincere effort to act upon it.

    With only 16 out of 131 seats in parliament, and 6% of the electorate vote, The ARF cannot achieve any of its goals or objectives for the betterment of the life of Amenians who are living in the Homeland.

    In my view, Mr. Mensoian has provided the basic elements of a clear and precise “Platform” on which the ARF can run  the Parliamentary elections in 2012.  The question is whether we shall have the right candidates to convey the message and do what is right. Without the Platform as described by  Mensoian, and capturing a larger block of seats in the parliament, the ARF will not be able to have any influence in Armenia, and its role will be limited to the Diaspora.

    Without popular support in Armenia, without the desire and the strong hope that things in Armenia will get better, the ARF’s efforts in the Diaspora will be in vein, unless we find a common cause with the citizens of the Homeland.

    Vart Adjemian    

        

  3. “In1991 the second independent Armenian republic was declared.”  —We can certainly say ‘second independent Armenian republic’, but equally correct would be to say ‘third Armenian republic’. Although dependent, Soviet Armenia nonetheless was our second republic.
     
    “The political implosion of the Soviet Union represented a complete failure of this ill-conceived Bolshevik experiment in socio-economic engineering, which resulted in an immediate and total collapse of Armenia’s economy attended by social and political chaos.”  —Modern scholars agree that the Bolshevik experiment wasn’t the primary reason for the political implosion of the Soviet Union: manipulated external factors, destructive outside forces, and home-bred treacherous individuals caused the collapse of otherwise relatively viable, yet non-competitive, Soviet (including Armenian) economy. One cannot but agree that Armenia’s Soviet period, even though it was an ill-conceived Bolshevik experiment, was one of the brightest in many respects.

  4. A sincerely concerned, but an unsubstantiated article, of the impressionist genre, full of factual errors (E.g. there were no parliamentary elections in May 1993 in Armenia) and with an abundance lack of information on the activities of the ARF-Dashnaktsutyun in Armenia. All this means that it is in desperate need of a response. So… stay tuned.

  5. Dear Mr.Mensoian                                                                                                                                          Your Article , where is the ARF of our fathers ,was proufoundly comprehensive   and needed  no comments but rather unquestionable apprehension and support  ,and it had the effect of looking into one’s own self in the mirror.and therefore it showed all in it’s full length and very clearly ,the shortcomings and miscalculations of the latest  generations  of leadership, so nothing could be added there except  trying to find  the answer  to your  question . 
           The  ARF  was  founded  having as a strategy ,not  the liberation of Armenia ,because at that time even the mere thought about it was extremely unlikely and an unrealistic dream. It was founded  to give a hand to the poor Armenian population in western Armenia by spreading among them the spirit of revolt against the Turkish and Kurdish oppressors,in plight of equal rights ,because the country was bleeding under the ottoman yoke ,and the Armenian population  unable to endure   any more were leaving the country by the thousands  in search of their daily bread,and a decent life , to foreign  countries, and the land was being emptied .It was   with remarkable and heroic stories  that the   fedayeens enriched our recent history with ..And the masses loved and adopted them in their hearts.
    That’s why when the ARF was eventually re-founded in  YERGIR ,the welcoming cries was heard all over,to the extend that  fables and ficticious stories  were invented about   DASHNAK armies in the diaspora  .People were waiting for them .
    Now the situation in Armenia is as it is known , and the ARF is there in  YERGIR ,with a  difference from the ARF of our fathers in its tactics .The ARF instead of bringing with it the ancestoral  virtues and moralities ,it fell into the trap knitted by the regime  , though innocentely,involuntarily , and in contrast  to its approved activity in western Armenia during the last century ,it did not succeed to be convincing to the ordinary people ,in modern Armenia, because it fell into the trap of participating in some of the governments and the people did not trust the authorities whatsoever .                                                To understand the political situation there even better ,we have to state that the ruling elite who came to power after the independence were almost the same elite of the communist era ,who naturally brought with it the  corruption and machiavelian intrigues the precedent regime was so famous with . The system itself was based on tempting all in power by  indirectly  imposing on them  corruption , because that way they could manipulate all and hold them in a state of dependency  .And this state of dependency is true for all whether in alliance or in opposition to the ruling class.So naturaly for the newly arrived  ARF, participating in the governments , was the reason for the start  of its downfall ,and loss of reputation  to the extent of humiliating negligence .                                                                                                                                   For the party to save itself from this dishonarable situation has to witness a total change in its  leadership to nurture the people with confidence towards it,and then start real struggle for the improvement of the social situation and the other problems .This not materialized the sympathy towards the ARF will not improve .                                                                                                                                                            As a conclusion we see that in fact the people having  no  hope in any positive change in their lives continue to immigrate which has reached to very critical levels and the future of the nation is really at stake,unless there would be a widespread people’s revolution  ,though unfortunately the Armenian history has not witnessed much such acts .I Wish that happens as soon as possible for the good of the people ,the country and the perpetuality of our nation.As for our beloved ARF,  that happening ,without it being the real pioneer , we   shall  be needing smaller and smaller halls to commemorate its future anniversaries…
    An anxious  partisan
     

Back to top button