Chidem Inch: “What is the future of our homeland?”

Like most everyone who reads this, I am feeling very sad and helpless. 

Armenians around the world knew it was likely this day would come, when our enemy would begin a military offensive to take Artsakh. We knew this was more likely than a favorable outcome for the Armenians. We have felt this way since the blockade of the Berdzor (Lachin) Corridor started over nine months ago. We have felt this way since Aliyev began referring to the Republic of Armenia as Western Azerbaijan.

We knew, but felt helpless to do anything about it. The government of the Republic of Armenia seemed unable to do anything either. The Prime Minister of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan recognized Artsakh as part of Azerbaijan earlier this year. Many in Armenia and the diaspora were appalled by this announcement and accused him of caving in, but no one offered any viable alternatives. 

Sadly, an alternative based on self-determination required the Armenians in Armenia or Artsakh to have a military capable of providing a military defense. The days of grabbing a rifle or pitchfork and heroically defending the homeland are well behind us. The only other option was to wait for another country to step in and make Azerbaijan and Turkey agree to terms favorable to the Armenians. Who would do this? Russia, the U.S., France or India? 

Countries rarely act on altruism. Look at the news. Our story is buried on page six, if anywhere. It is not the lead story. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky addressing the U.N. is a top story. The U.S. giving $24 billion in aid to Ukraine is a top story. We are an afterthought or no thought at all. The U.S. still gives aid to Azerbaijan. Yet the U.S. State Department made a statement:

The United States is deeply concerned by Azerbaijan’s military actions in Nagorno-Karabakh and calls on Azerbaijan to cease these actions immediately. These actions are worsening an already dire humanitarian situation in Nagorno-Karabakh and undermine prospects for peace.

Nice words. I can’t imagine they will have any more impact on the outcome in Artsakh than the words I am typing here. 

What is the best we hope for now? Will the U.S. and France provide evacuation and resettlement aid for the people of Artsakh? A guarantee of the sovereignty and borders of the Republic of Armenia? Who can possibly make and back-up such a guarantee? Does Armenia become a vassal state of…you tell me?

I am not a diplomat, in the leadership of any government or political party, or an expert in international affairs.

What do I know? I know that Artsakh is Armenian. We all know that to the core of our beings.

What do I know? I know that Artsakh is Armenian. We all know that to the core of our beings. Yet we seem to be the only people in the world to believe that. Borders were drawn a century ago, and everyone but us believes that land is now part of Azerbaijan. We cannot do anything to change that or what is happening in Artsakh. 

Armenians are in a very precarious position. What is the future of our homeland, our self-determination? I am not sure we even have a paper ladle these days.

Mark Gavoor
Mark Gavoor is Associate Professor of Operations Management in the School of Business and Nonprofit Management at North Park University in Chicago. He is an avid blogger and oud player.


  1. Great perspective Mark. And Khrimian Hayrik was a visionary clergyman and thought leader and more of a realist than many of the ‘cloth’. It does appear that we are all culpable for allowing the train to be diverted and in hindsight there are many things we should have built up. But here we are with no iron ladle and in a time when fabrication counts for fact. It seems as though things couldn’t be worse. And we think that we have our faith – but the scales no longer balance the way they did in 1915 – the world is desensitized and we appear to be alone. But we do have our faith and we do have each other. So get the fedayi songs ready once again – and get the iron hot for the ladle of today – bring the lobbyists and The Communication companies to the trough and we will fight on a new field of battle.

  2. I am so very sad this is happening. There seems to be no justice for the dear people of Armenia. Im sure it is very difficult to watch this happening.
    Thank you for exlaining & helping people like me who are not well read on the struggles of the Armenians get a better understanding.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.