Lisbon reminds me that we must avoid lapsing back into conformism.
NEW YORK–On Sun., July 28, the New York ARF “Armen Garo” Gomideh requested a Requiem Service and presented a program to mark the 30th anniversary of the Lisbon 5 event at the St. Illuminator Cathedral’s John Pashalian Hall.
Guest contributions to the Armenian Weekly are informative articles or press releases written and submitted by members of the community.
2 Comments
Is it proper to commemorate the deaths of Lisbon 5 ?
What about the Portuguese police officer ?
What about the Turkish civilian woman ?
.
To repeat from other threads: my position is that it _was_ proper (in 70s and 80s) to assassinate Turkish state actors – officers of the denialist State, who were engaged in proactive AG denialism – in precisely targeted operations (with no harm to bystanders: as was done by Mr. Gourgen Yanikian).
And I simply remember with sadness the lost lives of the 5 idealistic young men and the 2 innocent bystanders , but see neither honor nor glory in the operation:
-The operation was botched from the get go.
-An amateurish scouting visit to the Embassy alerted guards to a possible pending attack: more security was added
-On the day of the operation, one of the cars was recognized from the previous visit to the embassy and was challenged: one of the 5 was shot to death in a brief gun battle.
-The remaining 4 ran to the diplomat’s residence and took the wife and her underage son hostage (…son either escaped or was let go before the detonation)
-Armenians: let’s stop right there; is it or is it not true that 4 young Armenian men took cover _behind_ a Turkish civilian _woman_ to avoid getting shot ?
-Is there anything more to be said ?
.
And isn’t it also true that the Armenian Apostolic Church is strictly against suicide ?
And that Church canons strictly prohibit funeral services in case of suicide, except by special permission from the Primate ?
.
Are any of the facts above false ?
If they are not, then what exactly are we Armenians commemorating ?
Avery,
I agree with your post, except the following:
“my position is that it _was_ proper (in 70s and 80s) to assassinate Turkish state actors – officers of the denialist State, who were engaged in proactive AG denialism”
This is still murder, and wrong. I disagree that death is the proper answer to these individuals. And why 70s and 80s? Is it now wrong, but not back then?
And believe me, I understand the denialism, the pervasiveness of it, and how Turkey still continues to pursue this immoral and painful path. I don’t believe murder is the answer to it. Or even justice. Justice was served to Talat and his gang when the world community did nothing. But they were guilty of the bloody crimes.
What I want to see is when any of these guys are in a crowd of non-Turks, and they deny the genocide, that the entire room, rejects it, understands how disgusting it is, and that the denier feels that no-one is buying the Turkish crap. That is the just and long-lasting justice that I want.
Is it proper to commemorate the deaths of Lisbon 5 ?
What about the Portuguese police officer ?
What about the Turkish civilian woman ?
.
To repeat from other threads: my position is that it _was_ proper (in 70s and 80s) to assassinate Turkish state actors – officers of the denialist State, who were engaged in proactive AG denialism – in precisely targeted operations (with no harm to bystanders: as was done by Mr. Gourgen Yanikian).
And I simply remember with sadness the lost lives of the 5 idealistic young men and the 2 innocent bystanders , but see neither honor nor glory in the operation:
-The operation was botched from the get go.
-An amateurish scouting visit to the Embassy alerted guards to a possible pending attack: more security was added
-On the day of the operation, one of the cars was recognized from the previous visit to the embassy and was challenged: one of the 5 was shot to death in a brief gun battle.
-The remaining 4 ran to the diplomat’s residence and took the wife and her underage son hostage (…son either escaped or was let go before the detonation)
-Armenians: let’s stop right there; is it or is it not true that 4 young Armenian men took cover _behind_ a Turkish civilian _woman_ to avoid getting shot ?
-Is there anything more to be said ?
.
And isn’t it also true that the Armenian Apostolic Church is strictly against suicide ?
And that Church canons strictly prohibit funeral services in case of suicide, except by special permission from the Primate ?
.
Are any of the facts above false ?
If they are not, then what exactly are we Armenians commemorating ?
Avery,
I agree with your post, except the following:
“my position is that it _was_ proper (in 70s and 80s) to assassinate Turkish state actors – officers of the denialist State, who were engaged in proactive AG denialism”
This is still murder, and wrong. I disagree that death is the proper answer to these individuals. And why 70s and 80s? Is it now wrong, but not back then?
And believe me, I understand the denialism, the pervasiveness of it, and how Turkey still continues to pursue this immoral and painful path. I don’t believe murder is the answer to it. Or even justice. Justice was served to Talat and his gang when the world community did nothing. But they were guilty of the bloody crimes.
What I want to see is when any of these guys are in a crowd of non-Turks, and they deny the genocide, that the entire room, rejects it, understands how disgusting it is, and that the denier feels that no-one is buying the Turkish crap. That is the just and long-lasting justice that I want.