My Turn
Sassounian: NY Times Ad Depicts Obama as ‘Liar’

The Centennial commemorations of the Armenian Genocide were marked with unprecedented, and sometimes unexpected, developments.

The Centennial commemorations of the Armenian Genocide were marked with unprecedented, and sometimes unexpected, developments.
Already a subscriber?Log in here
Could it be that something important to the U.S. In this world has priority over this issue to the President, as it has with every other President before him? Maybe before self serving Rabbi Boteach shoots off his mouth( which he hasn’t done with previous presidents by the way) he should find out what it is, or perhaps, think! Calling Obama a liar for this rabbi is his customary self serving mode of placing himself in the spotlight.
Dr. Levine: would you say the same thing if President Obama had, in effect, denied the Jewish Holocaust (…after he became POTUS) ?
Using similar weasel words to avoid saying ‘Jewish Holocaust’ that he used to avoid using the expression ‘Armenian Genocide’.
Would it be OK if ‘something important’ to US necessitated that State Dept, you know, said something like: “….in order not to hurt the feelings of our NATO ally Germany, and the many German veterans of WW2 still alive in Germany, the Holocaust will henceforth officially be referred to as the great tragedy of Shoah: generally, non-Jewish peoples do not know the word and do not associate Shoah with Germans, so the Waffen SS veterans in Germany will not be offended: everybody happy (expect Jews)”.
“We can all sing Kumbaya now”.
So what exactly is it that Rabbi Boteach said that you object to ?
Didn’t Pres Obama in fact lie ? When running for President he did pledge to recognize the Armenian Genocide once elected.
After he was elected, he started using weasel words: so, yes, he did lie.
So what part of lying by President Obama, which Rabbi Boteach cited, is self-serving on his part ?
Sir: Isn’t your objection to the “Armenian Genocide” due to the fact that it _is_ “Armenian” and it _is_ “Genocide” ?
1) By your logic, the U.S. should always take the ‘practical’ position over the moral position, because ‘practical’ interests will always “ha[ve] priority” over moral interests that give no immediate material benefit. So I guess you would be okay with the U.S. denying the Holocaust if it meant that a good nuclear agreement with Iran could be finalized? Right? Come out and say it.
2) Even assuming the above is true, it would be in the U.S.’s practical interest to tell the truth about the Armenian Genocide, for many reasons. For one thing, it would show that the U.S. stands up for itself, and does not buckle to threats from its ‘allies’. This is important, because if the U.S. is seen to capitulate to threats from its ‘allies’, imagine how it would capitulate to threats from its enemies. If the U.S. can’t stand up even to Turkey, how can it stand up to Iran, or Russia, or North Korea? Second, keeping America’s promise about the Armenian Genocide would enhance the credibility of future promises that the U.S. makes to the world–a credibility that badly needs to be restored after that embarrassing Syria “red-line” debacle. And third, it would show that the U.S. does not whitewash jihad–which the genocide was. This is necessary to raise American’s low moral standing and help it recruit allies in the war against the Islamic State. Especially since America’s denial puts it on a collision course with the Pope, Christians all around the world have every reason to be suspicious of America’s resolve against today’s Islamist evil.
Dr. Levine,
While you have the right to disagree with or dislike Rabbi Shmuley, you make several factual and judgmental errors of your own:
1) Not all US presidents have had the same position on the Armenian Genocide. Pres. Reagan acknowledged it on April 22, 1981 in a Presidential Proclamation.
2) Do you think it is proper to deny a genocide to appease a fanatical Turkish dictator and offend the moral sensibility of people around the world? Can you think of a valid reason that would justify denial of the Jewish Holocaust?