Paylan: Let’s Correct This Historic Mistake Before It’s Too Late

Armenian Member of Turkish Parliament Garo Paylan of the Peoples’ Democratic Party (HDP) recently wrote the following op-ed for Istanbul-based biweekly Agos newspaper. Below is the English translation.

MP Garo Paylan at the HDP Parliamentary office in Ankara (Photo: Rupen Janbazian)


Last week, I was in Berlin for attending the conference organized in memory of Hrant Dink. The day after the conference, I had a meeting with a group of deputies in the Bundestag (Parliament). When I entered Reichstag building where Bundestag is located, I heard a very nice piano melody. I asked the people who welcomed me where the melody was coming from. “From the hall of general assembly,” they answered.

I couldn’t help to peek inside the hall. They said that there was an event for commemorating the Holocaust. The hall was full. All deputies, Chancellor Merkel, and ministers were present at the hall of the General Assembly. All of the parliament warmly applauded this piano recital and speeches in memory of the Holocaust.

I must admit my envy. The German Parliament was commemorating the victims of the great crime that was committed by Nazi government. I was coming from an entirely different atmosphere; from my country, where the atrocities of yesterday haven’t been acknowledged and the atrocities of today go on with impunity… I felt sorry for my country and went to the meeting with teary eyes…

Just a week before this meeting, I was banned from Turkish Parliament because I mentioned what happened to my people at the end of Ottoman period. While I, as an Armenian deputy, wasn’t allowed to speak about 102-years-old sins, all German deputies, leftists, rightists, members of the ruling and opposing parties, were sitting side by side with great self-confidence in confronting their mistakes. And none of them were thinking that they were defaming German identity as a result.


The Constitution That Odyan Wrote

In Turkey, looking at the pages of the history is getting more and more difficult. Let me tell you how I experienced it. One week before the commemoration event in Berlin, I began to talk about the proposed constitutional amendments by saying, “We are about to make a historic mistake.” I said, “We long for a social contract, which everyone living in our common homeland can call ‘my constitution’.”

My purpose was to take the deputies back to the days when the constitution was discussed in the Ottoman period. I wanted to remind them of the mistakes that were made then. In fact, few people know that our first constitution was written in 1876 by a committee consisting of various identities. [Member of Ottoman Parliament] Krikor Odyan was the one who wrote it. The constitution was suspended by Sultan Abdulhamid and a period of autocracy started, which continued until 1908. And you know the rest… Seeking democracy, the coup by Talat and Enver, and the great disaster…

Today, the Nationalist Movement Party (MHP) defines the proposed amendments that had been discussed in the parliament as “the constitution of the Turkish nation.” It frightens me, because Talat and Enver had a similar mentality when they tried to implement the constitution of the Turkish nation. They regarded some people as acceptable citizens, while they ignored others. In fact, they even exterminated some of the people. During 1913-1923, great massacres, genocides, population exchanges, and pogroms took place. We lost majority of Armenian, Syriac, Greek, and Jewish people.

However, when I told about these facts in the parliament, all hell broke loose. An unprecedented punishment was imposed on me because I said “genocide.” I was banned from the discussions for three sessions. My speech was deleted from the parliamentary minutes.

Many of my friends who read about the incident on internet said, “Garo, you are right, but is this the right time to speak about the genocide? We are heading towards a dictatorial regime.” This was understandable, because media was making a fuss about the word “genocide.” My two cognates made statements to the press and said that they found my speech “irrelevant and untimely.” I wasn’t surprised. Some people just bow down in times like these. Fear and worry are understandable feelings.


“Well Then, You Name It”

My purpose was not to say “genocide” at all costs, in the midst of the uproar caused by the discussion on the amendments. In fact, I have said “genocide” and “Armenian Genocide” many times in parliament. There was no trouble before. This time again, I called what happened to my people “genocide” just like I always do.

However, something different happen: insults and crisis. I said, “Well then, you name it,” to the ones who objected me. That night, the MHP threatened the [ruling] Justice and Development Party (AKP) not to support the proposed amendments if I was not punished. Thus, I was banned from the parliament with the votes of the AKP, MHP, and the Republican People’s Party (CHP). I was subjected to the lynching campaign of the nationalist front.

I didn’t intend to cause controversy; my purpose was to make people learn from the past and prevent them from making the same mistakes. I wanted to talk about how the process of writing a constitution at the end of the Ottoman period led a pluralist society to a mentality of homogeneity, about the abuses and disasters caused by one-man-regimes, and about what all of this mean to us, who are trying to write a constitution in 2017.

I know very well that what happened to my grandfather and the great disasters took place in Anatolia were caused by the mistakes that politicians like us made. A system that abolishes the parliament would recreate the dreadful atmosphere created by Talat and Enver who abolished the same parliament. The proposed constitution makes the government dependent on one person; it imposes ideology of homogeneity. This is nothing but the repetition of the disasters that took place in the past.

I am aware of it and not talking about it would make me feel like I am betraying this country, these lands, and the people that I live with.


We Can Win Together

I am worried. The parliament that took action for “writing the constitution of the Turkish nation,” imprisoned Kurdish deputies with great enthusiasm and doesn’t have enough confidence to let its members vote secretly; no good can come of this.

Think about it. The Christian and Jewish peoples, who constituted 40% in the past, are just one out of 1,000 now, because of a mentality seeking for homogeneity. We suffered gravely. However, it is not only us; everyone is missing something. Everyone is tainted because of the mistakes of a couple of men.

For me, the problem is not only about the violation of my freedom of expression in the parliament, disrespect to the elected will, or whether I cannot use that word. These are important, of course, but what really matters is this: Turkey is determined to take the path about which its own history warns, is heading at full speed towards intolerance and an authoritarian regime that lacks a mechanism of balance and control.

The ones who will be ignored by the new period will either lapse into silence or revolt, or they will simply leave the country. Just like 100 years ago, the country will be damaged and impaired. We might live in a period during which we all lose.

However, we can win together.

On these tormented lands, in which we buried Hrant Dink 10 years ago, everyone lives in the restlessness of a dove. This restlessness is not groundless. We Armenians know it too well. That is why I am addressing you, the majority.

Let’s correct this historic mistake before it’s too late.


Guest Contributor

Guest Contributor

Guest contributions to the Armenian Weekly are informative articles written and submitted by members of the community, which make up our community bulletin board.


  1. BRAVO Garo Paylan! Turkey,the world and Armenians in Hayastan (Armenia) and all over the world need a HERO like you.
    May God bless you & protect you from the evil members in Turkey’s government and keep you away from harm & persecution.

  2. We Canada are still trying to make a contribution to the resolution of the Armenian Genocide by way of our project War Children for Peace and the Resolution of the Armenian Genocide. My late father in law Kerop Bedoukian was Armenian from Sivas. Kerop recalled his survival as a ten year old in THE URCHIN, which he wrote in honor of his mother who made his survival possible.

    • Kerop Bedoukian’s book “The Urchin”, which also is known as “Some of us Survived, brilliantly captures the experience of a young boy during the Genocide. I highly recommend it.

  3. Paylan is a hero. He is a human rights activist that deserves the attention of major powers. His message must be amplified by Armenia. The US and EU must stop their policies of turning a blind eye on what’s happening in Turkey. It is shameful for the US and EU to keep silent on the slaughter of Kurdish people and minorities. Imagine if this was happening in China or Russia what would the US do?

  4. very sad but would you expect anything else from the turkish parliament? they are blind to the facts and the TRUTH and you cannot change their attitude. They have a problem without doubt and that also stems from other prominent countries who have and still refuse for political reasons to avoid the word “Genocide” – yes! include israel with the others who have failed to acknowledge the atrocities and the genocide. For that,”shame on all those countries who have avoided the TRUTH for political and financial gain”.

  5. Turkish Troops are currently occupying North Cyprus, North Iraq, North Syria and West Armenia. All oppressed people need to unite against the Turkish aggressors

  6. Mr. Garo Paylan,
    you have a great heart for your homeland, unfortunately it doesn’t exist anymore politically or geographically, in fact it stopped existing close to 900 years ago. You might be born and bred in Turkey however you are deluding yourself in thinking a Turko-Mongol bunch of goat herders are going to listen to your call. You are like John the Baptist calling out in the wilderness. If you really want to help your homeland why not cross the border to the Republic of Armenia and use your political expertise to save what is actually your present geographical homeland. If R.O. Armenia can become politically and economically strong in the region then your dream could come true in the future. lamenting on others success or failures will not bring us the glory you envision for the Armenian people. Other countries and groups are very strongly organized politically and psychologically, and use their combined power to help and aid their actual homeland. if the Armenian people continue to be divided and shed tears on others successes we will continue to be beggars in the international political realm. As Nietzsche said we must have the will to power and not think if Turks, Germans or whoever should even care to help us, if we first cannot show a united front to these entities about and around our present homeland Republic of Armenia.
    Best Wishes
    John C

  7. Dear Garo,

    this is another Garo! I wish to honour your bravery in the face of ‘insults and crisis’.

    The comment “Garo, you are right, but is this the right time to speak about the genocide?” illustrates the fragile nature of the Armenian desire for acknowledgement and justice. There is never a right time, because there will always be strategic difficulties with Turkey & its allies – whether it is in relation to Syria, EU membership etc.

    A bully [the Turkish Government) has to be confronted with the truth (genocide) otherwise they will continue to enforce their distortion of our shared history.

    My respects

    Garo Derounian, UK

  8. Dear Garo,
    It is a great honor and pleasure to know that the voice of Truth sounds in the citadel of Turkish nationalists, and this is the voice of a brave and honest Armenian who dares to do it in the atmosphere of fear and hatred.
    You are doing a very important job. This is necessary for all, first of all for Turks. They must cure this disease just as Germans did. Please know that your efforts will bring their fruits. Millions of good will people of different faiths believe in you and support you.

  9. Garo Paylan’s analysis of the proposed Turkish Constitutional amendments and historical parallels are extremely relevant today. The political movement in Turkey to strengthen the Presidency at the expense of the Parliament is very dangerous. The three political parties teaming up to ban dissent could lead to a frightening outcome in the near future. We all know what happened 100 years ago.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.