Agritourism in Armenia: Monetizing a Culture of Hospitality

(A.W)—Armenia gained its independence from the Soviet Union 19 years ago this year. Since then, the country has made great strides in attracting tourists to the country, but the tourism industry still has room for growth. The World Travel and Tourism Council reports that the tourism industry represents 9.2 percent of the world’s gross domestic product and employs 235 million people. Given more investment and entrepreneurial insight, agritourism is one untapped opportunity within the industry in Armenia.
About half a million Diasporan Armenians visit Armenia each year, but the tourism products and services offered are largely limited to religious sites and destinations like Lake Sevan. Even native Armenians are leaving the country for their holidays. Armenia’s Ministry of Economy 2009 Report stated that 516,000 people traveled to other countries in 2008 for tourism, which is more than a 10 percent increase from a year earlier.




Another gem by Ms. Rendahl:
I love this woman (…figure of speech,….similar to Bill Clinton’s “…I love you man…”).
Learn something new from her articles every time – which explore unusual topics others don’t: get ideas of new, unusual things to do to benefit RoA and her people.
She has a level of deep insight into Armenia and Armenians, that frankly many (ethnic) Armenians don’t.
Kudos to ArmenianWeekly for giving her a forum.
Yep, good read!
I appreciate your enthusiasm, Avery! And I echo your kudos to the Armenian Weekly and its esteemed editor!
Strengthen Armenia’s economy? Yes! Turn traditional Armenian hospitality into a commodity. No!!
Kristi, excellent article and a lot to be learn.
I am doing something new, and i invite you to review our website “Hyelandz.Com” – it will be ready and running within a week.
I am retired Armenian-American, and i’d love to hear from you and your comments.
I have started the preparation of Hyelandz four years ago, and i am hoping it will be ready running this spring! Thank you
Congratulations for a very informative and very well researched article.
I just wrote my piece re above Ms. Rendahlh´s very informative post.Indeed it is very important .that of Agritourism.But i wish ,with her permission to add my share to it.
While a student in London England long ago,I knew that students who so wished would go to extend their help as FARM hands,spenind a 2 weeks or so in the country.While it was healthy,to work hard and eat good farm food there,they also thus helped the farmers.
But indeed my below is another suggestion,as Ms. Kristis,not same as above,but somehow related.Thus.-
Since 5 yrs been working hard to get Spiritual Tourism going in RA/Artsakh,while atending many a symposium ion politicla econimcal related in Yerevan.My Projection is the following.-Spiritual Tourism, which i tried hard with Tour info , historian that keeps very well showing on T.V. the unfortunate stance of some of these monasteries around Yerevan and further away..these need REPAIRS.Gaytzag, me that is, has thought to have 3 DAY Kermez-FAIR, DONAVAJAR around each of these.While sending our reps. of Touristic Agencies to get the Villagers around such monasteries to prepare for the sadi 3 DAY event brining their FAR,handicrafts and traditional foods fruits etc., to seel, there.The Ground to be flattened or readied for Tent/Camping for Armenian youthe FRO US,Canda Argentian france else plus regular tourists from anywhere to attend.How? by all more 3 ozen touristic agencies in yerevan to adevertise , in their booklets before hand and St. Etch miadzinb to send for theFIRST DAY ONLY a pries to conduct mass, ETC., .vILLAGERS/FARMERS TO CONTRIBUTE SOME pARTICIPATION fee FOR THEIR STANDS ALSO OTHER WHO WISH TO HAVE STAND AT THE fairs,THUS WITH PROCEEDS THE COMMITTEE THAT WILL BE SET UP TO HAELP PREPARE ,REPAIR AND BUILD LAVATORIES ADJACENT TO SUCH MONASTERIES FOR THE VISITORS ETC.,Then the Stand that repressent Ms. krisits Agritourism thereat can attract the young for same year or next to participate as FARM hadn at given FARms that wish to have theses young come ,learn help and be healthy eatinc good farm food there…
Spiritual Tourism can help REPAIR those monateries ,while enhancing Tourism of Agricultural one etc., ewt., etc.,
i shall if get time write in this respect to her.I already have two ladies in armenian associated with the Spiritual head(s) of _Regions there thinking of same and ONE Tourist Agency recently in contact with me.
Thanks to Ms. Kristi again for good insight and hard work
Arthur – I’ll look forward to visiting your website once it’s up and running!
Thanks for your comment, Ananoon. There can be a fine line between leveraging the long-standing traditions of hospitality and “selling out.” Call me crazy, but I believe that Armenians can maintain the authenticity of their hospitality while also improving their economic situation. Of course the notion of agritourism is not a panacea, but one opportunity for diversification. It is especially important for rural areas, which are facing increased out-migration and left with primarily aging populations. This becomes an even more critical issue when we consider depopulation in the border regions.
Thanks, Antoine. You are a model for the Armenian World in launching these very kinds of projects. Apres and keep up the good work!
Kristi,
What an exciting, opportunity-filled article! It is an opportunity to help the struggling small farmer in our country; to get to know the rural districts that are off the main roads; to experience the solitude and peace and simplicity of a rural holiday. An opportunity to get away from life in the fast lane, the computer, the tv, the cell, the constant din of traffic, to recoup in clean air eating simple, clean food, while at the same time helping our small farmers and their families.
I have never been able to find a site where I can make a microloan to an Armenian farm woman. As you no doubt know, the ability to own a cow, or even to have a share in one, to buy bees to start a hive, chickens to farm eggs, a goat, some sheep, changes lives. I have at times been given as a Christmas gift, a card saying that a microloan had been made in my name to a woman who needed help with her farming. Sometimes it was to buy an animal, at times to buy hand tools. This is such an exciting, rewarding thing to be able to do. Just think; to help buy 2 sheep means that a woman can shear them and spin yarn and dye it with the local vegetation and then knit articles to sell! Who would not want to own such a hat or mittens or sweater? And why would you not pay her top dollar for them, knowing that the money would help her to expand her little business. It takes so little to help her buy those sheep. She can milk her sheep and make cheese to sell. I am not surprised that you wrote “Two farmers, both women, said with conviction, “We can do this. And we can do it better.” These women can make changes in the lives of their families. It also gives them a sense of self-esteem and pride, and improved status within the home, to be able to help provide for the family. I do not agree with Ananoon. I think we should be more than willing to pay top prices, and more, and not go with inflated western expectations of hotel service, but rather, to go with humility and hope that we can help them better their lives.
Do you know of a site for microloans for rural Armenian women?
Kristi, the article was really very nice and informative.
Thank you. I’ll keep you informed as soon as our website is ready.
We hope you could visit Hyelandz one day and share your impressions with us.
Thank you.
DEAAR kRISTI ET AL,
Firstly, I wish to apologize for bad erroneous writing.You see -secondly- I´m old near 80,months left to complete..but my request to you was to find out if my ¨suggestions¨as rgds having YOUTH and even Young men ,Young women going to Armenia/Artsakh be guided to go to WORK ON FARMS , for short stunts of 2 weeks or so.If you believe it is not a good idea then be it.Otherwise,please let me know,since I also wrote to you at the e-mail address you had furnished us with in this rgd.
Thanks in advance,
G.P.
Thanks so much, Perouz. There are a couple of interesting programs (at least) that speak to your interest of assisting rural women. You can look into providing loans through Kiva’s operations in Armenia. Also, you might consider donating to Heifer Armenia. Those are just two off the top of my head.
Dear Gaytzag,
I wholeheartedly agree that farm stays would be a wonderful way to learn about rural Armenian culture. Some of the farmers I spoke with were very interested in the prospect of hosting people, and even letting them work on the farm or in their gardens. As you likely know, it is a major concession for an Armenian to let a guest work in their home! At present, I think it’s possible to arrange through creative tour agencies or other contacts, but it’s not common. If more people ask for it, though, I believe the tour agencies and villagers will respond!
Dear Kristi,
Just discovered you and I am delighted to have done so…..read all your past entries too, and find them most moving….I too love Armenia, and an anxious to see success stories as you have written…..I look forward to reading more about your experiences…
If you are ever in the NYC area, please let me know….I would love to meet you and have you make a presentation at our Church in White Plains.
Sirov,
George
Thank you again Kristi for opening up this discussion and providing such good replies to the issues raised.
There are many things that can be done by the readers of the AW to help in the win/win efforts of promoting tourism in Armenia (whether eco, agro, rural, spiritual…). Ideas are great, but contacts and a promotion effort are essential. Local Armenian tour operators and travel agencies cannot do it alone.
The volunteering initiatives can very well coalesce with rural tourism. Kristi has already created “Habitat For Humanity – Armenia” which, in my perspective, is a successful hybrid between generous people volunteering to work on building someone’s house and these same people enjoying some rural tourism. Israel has very successfully attracted (non-Jewish) volunteers to work on kibbutzs. I have sent several young tourists to participate for a day or two in the grape harvest in our ‘Areni’ region. This initiative could be improved if the volunteer grape pickers could (like Kibbutz volunteers) come for the complete harvest season and then have the pleasure to participate in a better organised social function at the end e.g. a dance-filled ‘wine festival’ (they are too tired at the end of a hard working day to do much), see for example the photos here: http://www.flickr.com/photos/aterjanian/sets/72157600803341470/
The Kiva micro-loans idea is also good. Kiva ‘could’ give loans for rural dwellers to improve at least one room and their bathroom facilities, so more of our people can offer rooms with acceptable western standards to tourists and at the same time improve their own standard of living. We have given such loans to our neighbours and they are now very happy to welcome tourists. Incidentally this also answers the concern expressed by “Ananoon”, the tourist can make the payment directly towards paying back the loan.
Most important, let us all get involved and follow Kristi’s example.
AST
Dear George,
Thanks so much for writing. I’d be delighted to speak at your church sometime. And it’s easy to convince me to visit NYC.
Mets sirov,
Kristi
You are very kind, Antoine. There are so many people doing good things in and for Armenia.
Dear Kristi,
Thanks for your kind and prompt reply. I shall let you know when and if ONE Tour Agency,in particular agrees to cooperation,such as continually advertising in their Brochures re STUDENT programme to go to work on Famrs in RA/Artsakh.
The other party ,that of the spiritual Tour ladies are there waiting my/our decision to go.
Kind rgds,
G.P:
The fine article on “Agritourism in Armenia” by Kristi Rendahl was thought provoking! For me it was also mind wandering of memories of volunteer farm work during World War !! Able bodied farm workers were being drafted for military service stranding marginal farms of labor.
The U.S. Dept. of Agriculture came up with a scheme to use volunteer youth age 16 to 18 to work on labor short farms. It was called “Victory Farm Volunteers” and taken up by many youth groups, the Boy Scouts being one of them. Haig Bogossian, of Brooklyn, NY, was one of them who volunteered and upon returning to our Scout Troop, told stories of the healthy lifestyle working on a dairy farm far up in Vermont complete with great photos.
So, I too volunteered and worked on a dairy farm which was still milking cows by hand having been electrified in 1942 and that only the barn and barn yard! Water was from a piped spring and toilet was the familiar out house.
This is what I imagine many of the Armenian farms to be from the stories I have read in this newspaper. Young people travel to Armenia and take part in many worth while projects. Perhaps volunteering to work on remote country farms is feasible, not only helping the farm family but gaining an insight of the hardship underwhich they live to feed the many visitors to Armenia.
Seems to be a nice idea, but I personally think that there are a number of obstacles to overcome –
1. The high airplane tickets make travels to Armenia quite expensive for foreigners, so the only realistic market is the Armenian Diaspora who periodically return home. The latter, however, have enough friends and relatives at villages, so the need for agritourism is minimal. I think there is no sense to make efforts in this direction until the transportation problem is there, so this becomes a political rather than economic issue.
2. Why all those NGOs mentioned above make effort to develop agritourism? Just because they catch European and American grant money and try to launder them through the system making a beautiful impression that they are doing that great philanthropic work. Believe me that most of the NGOs mentioned above are gradually becoming commercially oriented and more and more often they become just simple businesses involved in import and/or trade of goods. Take CARD for example, it imports to Armenia the John Deer super-expensive machinery and makes its members buy them though its leasing organization. It is just an importer and retailer, rather than supportive organization. Why won’t it import cheaper machinery from Europe, Ukraine, or even China, huh? Then it imports all the German organic cosmetics and chocolate instead of supporting local producers. So it creates forced competition to local produce. Take even Green Lane, it sells its “organic” products to foreign clients, so it is directly involved in commercial activities, leaving under a huge question the source of that “organic”, and just putting a few nice pictures of hard working farmers on its website. Therefore none of those NGOs actually bring any sustainability to Armenia, UNFORTUNATELY!
3. The initiative should come from villagers themselves. What they need? Just simple consulting and a bit training and leading. May be a few trips to Europe and the US as an encouragement, then this will be sustainable. And you can throw away all those supportive NGOs, Organizations, Associations, together with their multi-member staff members, fancy cars, and sweet promises.
4. At this stage even if agritourism can work in Armenia, only to a very low level and certain extent, which will not make any positive impact on the farmers’ income.
Thanks for taking the time to share your stories and draw that parallel, Vahram. There is much to be learned from history.
Thank you for your thoughtful comments, Armen. You’re quite right that the cost of transportation remains a problem for any type of tourism in Armenia; that also came up in interviews, as noted in the article. As for the role of NGOs in this field and others, I think it’s good to view many things with a healthy degree of skepticism, but I’m loathe to dismiss them as completely ineffective and mal-intentioned.
I fully agree that agritourism should stem from the farmers/villagers themselves. What is impeding that at present is simply insight on the types of activities that would be marketable, the awareness that such a market exists, and the necessary connections between themselves/their services and that market. After I simply presented some examples of agritourism to farmers, they quickly adapted the concepts to their own environment and articulated how they could make it happen with little to no investment. It’s certainly not a panacea, but it’s a tool to be considered within a larger strategic framework for rural development.
Mr. Kemkemian:
Every drop counts!
A lot of the criticism you voice is well founded. On the other hand, Armenia and its tourism industry have made giant leaps since the dark ages of the 90’s.
Yes, airtickets are relatively expensive, but how do you explain the steady growth in tourism since 2000? Not all of the tourists/volunteers came from neighboring countries or from Europe.
Yes, NGO’s can be inefficient and have considerable unnecessary expenses and overhead, but some of them do achieve something, and have contributed in someway to the recent advance. But if this overhead bothers you, perhaps, when you are ready to do it, you could finance your own projects with “zero overhead” like I have been doing.
I do appreciate the recommendations and the criticism you provide, and if you are not yet personally involved, in the field, I hope you will join. You ARE needed.
Nice article!
I was glad to read that so many people from so many NGOs are enthusiastic about development of agritourism in Armenia. However, I have an impression that most of the people interviewed confuse terms “trip/visit, tourism, rural tourism, agritourism, etc”. So, introduction of clarity into those concepts and common understanding of what is what, can do real steps towards development of rural visits/trips, rural tourism, agritourism, and mass tourism in Armenia.